Lot 701    

Display of Custer Little Big Horn Relics,
2006, Firearms and Early Militaria Auction, Dec 7
comprising an ummounted 2” x 3.25” albumen photograph of “Lt. Col. G.A. Custer” tipped to paper along with a purported silk “remnant” of 7th Cavalry colors and newspaper clipping referring to a “Mr. Schirmacher, one the heroes of the Yellowstone campaign under Custer,” and three spent .45-70 “brass shell casings” said to be relics from “the Custer battlefield at the Little Big Horn,” all mounted together under modern glass. With a photocopied notarized “Letter of Authenticity” given November 15, 2000 by a noted national dealer in Civil War militaria. The albumen is from the March 1876 series by photographer D.F. Barry (see Katz) showing Custer in the full dress uniform (helmet trimmed away) of his famous 7th Cavalry Regiment while the three .45-70s are correct cartridges for the issue Model 1873 Springfield trapdoor carbine with provenance not specified.

The section of silk bunting sits adjacent to a description that reads in full: Remnant of the only one of the colors of the 7th US cavalry saved from the Battle of the Little Big Horn, June 25, 1876 (picked up on the field). The accompanying “letter of authenticity” states that the fragment was at one time owned by the Goodspeed Book Shop at which time it was framed. It was originally owned by Pvt. Schirmacher, one of Colonel Custer’s troopers, referred to in the undated newspaper clipping. Despite the stated provenance the “flag remnant" could not possibly have been recovered from the Little Big Horn battlefield and is more likely a period piece of worn red/white/blue bunting imbued with late 19th century Custer mystique by Schirmacher, if indeed, we accept that he was the original owner. First and foremost, the remnant, roughly 3” x 5”, is made of thin silk, a material too fragile for field use, lightly machine stitched with a single strand of white cotton thread suitable only for a parade. Second, the precise details of both flags carried by the 7th Cavalry at the Little Big Horn are known and neither can physically match the cut and configuration of this purported narrow red/white/blue piece. The 7th Cavalry carried a regulation swallow-tail guidon made of heavy reinforced silk having a fly of red and white stripes with square blue union upper left containing two circular rows of 31 gold stars with four more stars at each corner. The second flag carried at Little Big Horn was Custer’s personal headquarters banner made by Libby Custer and it, too, was a swallow-tail design with equal horizontal stripes of red over blue with two large white crossed sabers in the center.

The regimental standard of the 7th Cavalry was not carried at the Little Big Horn while cavalry regiments were not authorized national colors—stars and stripes—until 1895. An examination of a photograph or diagram of a regulation cavalry guidon (which remained essentially unchanged from 1862 until 1885) it is evident that it is quite impossible to duplicate—even by selective cutting—the configuration of this remnant. It is speculative to suggest what Schirmacher’s symbolic remnant might be, but it is with a high degree of certainly not a relic of the 1876 Custer battlefield.

Property of the former First National Bank of Fremont, Indiana

Silk and cartridges RELIC, heavily trimmed albumen VG.
Sold: $977.50
Price includes
Buyer's Premium
      Ask a Question

All Images

don't miss

an opportunity to bid. You can't win if you're not in.

sign up to bid

what's it worth?

ask the experts

sell your item

start selling
* 4780 Ballard Carbine,
Lot # 371 - * 4780 Ballard Carbine,
.44 caliber, serial number 5105, 22" part- octagonal, part-round barrel. Top of the barrel stamped Worcester, Mass. Left flat stamped Merwin & Bray Agts, New York. Right flat stamped Ballard's Patent Nov. 5, 1861. Complete with two swivel rings. > Item Details
Civil War Bugle
Lot # 248 - Civil War Bugle
11" brass bugle with ornately beaded mouthpiece. Complete with yellow double woven cords terminating in acorn formed tassels. > Item Details
290 Lot of Two Cannon Balls
Lot # 528 - 290 Lot of Two Cannon Balls
first with 1" aperture for powder cavity, 10lb. 4.5" diameter. > Item Details
Tenn. Milita? Dress Frock Coat,
Lot # 251 - Tenn. Milita? Dress Frock Coat,
cadet jacket with groups of 9 buttons in three columns going down the front of the jacket. Each button with the Great Seal of Tennessee. Ornate frog pattern stitched horizontally across the front in green wool thread. Gold bullion on both collars plus green loops stitched into each shoulder. Both s... > Item Details
Southerner Handgun,
Lot # 715 - Southerner Handgun,
.41 rimfire, 2.5" octagonal barrel, serial number 5889. Brass frame, steel barrel, and rosewood grips. > Item Details
Belgian Percussion Single-Shot Muff Pistol,
Lot # 861 - Belgian Percussion Single-Shot Muff Pistol,
.50 caliber, 2.5" barrel. Folding trigger. Liege proof on left side of frame. Screw barrel and fruitwood grips. > Item Details
4833 Whitney Percussion Navy Revolver, Second Model, Second Type,
Lot # 148 - 4833 Whitney Percussion Navy Revolver, Second Model, Second Type,
.36 caliber, 7.5" octagonal barrel, stamped on top E.Whitney/N. Haven. Walnut grips and brass trigger guard. > Item Details
Civil War Period Cavalry Bridle Bit,
Lot # 511 - Civil War Period Cavalry Bridle Bit,
unmarked, made of iron with single fancy rosette having raised C, closely approximating the M1851 Dragoon bit in profile except for the integral reinforcement arms added to the top of the branch. Forward portion of bit at branch support bar slightly bent at angle. > Item Details
Collins & Co. Hartford,CT Knife,
Lot # 905 - Collins & Co. Hartford,CT Knife,
Bowie-style knife, 10.25" blade marked Collins and No. 17. Complete with leather sheath. 15" overall length. > Item Details
Revolutionary War Era Halberd Head,
Lot # 12 - Revolutionary War Era Halberd Head,
16.5" steel cruciform spear point complete with tomahawk-shaped blade and spike-shaped beak. Conical socket with pair of 4.5" straps with two mounting holes. Forged as one integral piece. > Item Details
5330 Archive of C.S.A. Lt. Richard P. Lake, w/ Three Handguns,
Lot # 230 - 5330 Archive of C.S.A. Lt. Richard P. Lake, w/ Three Handguns,
includes a Colt Model 1816 Army Percussion Revolver. .44 caliber, 8" barrel with faded single-line NY address stampings, serial number 17864 on frame, trigger guard and backstrap. Barrel is stamped with different serial number 22843. Four-screw frame, left frame stamped Colt's Patent and .44 Cal. PL... > Item Details
1832 Belt with Sabre Frog Hanger State of New York
Lot # 164 - 1832 Belt with Sabre Frog Hanger State of New York
two-piece brass buckle marked S.N.Y. White buff leather belt and sword hanger. [See O'Donnell, 1996: 175, pl. 257]. > Item Details
4812 <i>American Gun Co</i> Half Stock Hammer Double-Barreled Shotgun
Lot # 827 - 4812 American Gun Co Half Stock Hammer Double-Barreled Shotgun
410 gauge, 26" barrel, serial number 4976. Left lockplate stamped American Gun Co. NY. Double trigger and brass beaded front sight. Walnut stock and forearm with a nice checkered pattern. > Item Details
4823 Model1849 Colt Five-Shot Revolver,
Lot # 104 - 4823 Model1849 Colt Five-Shot Revolver,
31 caliber, serial number 256165, 6" octagonal barrel stamped Address Col. Saml Colt New York, US America. All serial numbers matching. > Item Details
Pair of Civil War Shackles,
Lot # 517 - Pair of Civil War Shackles,
first pair stamped Prov Tool Co. on both cuffs. Complete with functional key. Second item with single iron cuff and functional key. > Item Details
Indian Wars Era Field Bugle,
Lot # 825 - Indian Wars Era Field Bugle,
stamped Selmer, presumably Henri Selmer/Paris on the mouth piece, otherwise unmarked. Of typical 19th century all brass construction, valveless, measuring about 18” long, this specimen with two bands of brass reinforcements and detachable mouthpiece. With brass attachment ring for carrying sling. Th... > Item Details
Civil War Officer's Sash
Lot # 153 - Civil War Officer's Sash
red worsted wool sash terminating in two tassels. > Item Details
M 1855 Sabre Bayonet
Lot # 480 - M 1855 Sabre Bayonet
brass handle saber bayonet with steel blade. Leather scabbard with brass fittings. Unmarked blade. Blade length is 21.75". Overall length is 16.75". Top of the brass handle stamped with a number 4. > Item Details
4782 Remington  New York Stat Contract Rolling Block Carbine,
Lot # 380 - 4782 Remington New York Stat Contract Rolling Block Carbine,
.50-70 centerfire, 22" barrel stamped B on left flat. Tang stamped Remington's Ilion, N.Y., U.S.A. Pat. May 3rd, Nov 15th, 1864, April 17 1866, Aug 27th 1867, Nov 7th 1871. Left wrist with inspector's cartouche HBH. Stenciled numbers on the wood; A 125. Complete with small slide bar and saddle ring.... > Item Details
Cased Remington Arms Pistol,
Lot # 738 - Cased Remington Arms Pistol,
.41 rimfire caliber, 3" barrel, serial number L7532. Nickel-plated, hard rubber grips. Case is not original to the gun. > Item Details
ITEMS 1-20 of 20