Lot 701    

Display of Custer Little Big Horn Relics,
2006, Firearms and Early Militaria Auction, Dec 7
comprising an ummounted 2” x 3.25” albumen photograph of “Lt. Col. G.A. Custer” tipped to paper along with a purported silk “remnant” of 7th Cavalry colors and newspaper clipping referring to a “Mr. Schirmacher, one the heroes of the Yellowstone campaign under Custer,” and three spent .45-70 “brass shell casings” said to be relics from “the Custer battlefield at the Little Big Horn,” all mounted together under modern glass. With a photocopied notarized “Letter of Authenticity” given November 15, 2000 by a noted national dealer in Civil War militaria. The albumen is from the March 1876 series by photographer D.F. Barry (see Katz) showing Custer in the full dress uniform (helmet trimmed away) of his famous 7th Cavalry Regiment while the three .45-70s are correct cartridges for the issue Model 1873 Springfield trapdoor carbine with provenance not specified.

The section of silk bunting sits adjacent to a description that reads in full: Remnant of the only one of the colors of the 7th US cavalry saved from the Battle of the Little Big Horn, June 25, 1876 (picked up on the field). The accompanying “letter of authenticity” states that the fragment was at one time owned by the Goodspeed Book Shop at which time it was framed. It was originally owned by Pvt. Schirmacher, one of Colonel Custer’s troopers, referred to in the undated newspaper clipping. Despite the stated provenance the “flag remnant" could not possibly have been recovered from the Little Big Horn battlefield and is more likely a period piece of worn red/white/blue bunting imbued with late 19th century Custer mystique by Schirmacher, if indeed, we accept that he was the original owner. First and foremost, the remnant, roughly 3” x 5”, is made of thin silk, a material too fragile for field use, lightly machine stitched with a single strand of white cotton thread suitable only for a parade. Second, the precise details of both flags carried by the 7th Cavalry at the Little Big Horn are known and neither can physically match the cut and configuration of this purported narrow red/white/blue piece. The 7th Cavalry carried a regulation swallow-tail guidon made of heavy reinforced silk having a fly of red and white stripes with square blue union upper left containing two circular rows of 31 gold stars with four more stars at each corner. The second flag carried at Little Big Horn was Custer’s personal headquarters banner made by Libby Custer and it, too, was a swallow-tail design with equal horizontal stripes of red over blue with two large white crossed sabers in the center.

The regimental standard of the 7th Cavalry was not carried at the Little Big Horn while cavalry regiments were not authorized national colors—stars and stripes—until 1895. An examination of a photograph or diagram of a regulation cavalry guidon (which remained essentially unchanged from 1862 until 1885) it is evident that it is quite impossible to duplicate—even by selective cutting—the configuration of this remnant. It is speculative to suggest what Schirmacher’s symbolic remnant might be, but it is with a high degree of certainly not a relic of the 1876 Custer battlefield.

Provenance:  
Property of the former First National Bank of Fremont, Indiana


Condition:  
Silk and cartridges RELIC, heavily trimmed albumen VG.
Sold: $977.50
Price includes
Buyer's Premium
      Ask a Question

All Images

WWII Naval Lt. Pay Clerks Jacket, Plus,
Lot # 943 - WWII Naval Lt. Pay Clerks Jacket, Plus,
three buttons in two columns on face of jacket. Brass buttons with patriotic eagle with fouled anchor. Both cuffs with gold bullion bands and gold bullion Paymaster's leaf insignia. PLUS, leather surveyor's pouch PLUS, military silk map of the Philippines dated April 1944, PLUS Vietnam War era Parat... > Item Details
* Japanese Rifle, WWII,
Lot # 977 - * Japanese Rifle, WWII,
7.7mm, 25.5" barrel, serial number 47790. Arsenal of manufacture is the Torinatsu Factory of Nagoya. Front barrel band is two-screw-type, cleaning rod, wood stock, and sling swivels. > Item Details
Non-Regulation  Beaverskin Col Z. R. Bliss," width="224" />
Col Z. R. Bliss,">Lot # 63 - Non-Regulation Beaverskin "Pork Pie" Slouch Hat ID'd to Col Z. R. Bliss,
brass three-quarter laurel wreath badge with US pin. Silver bullion hat cords terminating with pair of acorn finials. Black ribbon silk hatband encompassing base of hat. Inside of hat with glazed cotton liner stamped Col. Z. R. Bliss. Brim is 2.25" wide and hat is 4.25" height. Colonel Zenas Randall... > Item Details
Fox Double Barrel Shotgun,
Lot # 826 - Fox Double Barrel Shotgun,
14 gauge, 31" barrels. Back-action locks, silver fox inlays in ovals on both lockplates. > Item Details
* 4780 Ballard Carbine,
Lot # 371 - * 4780 Ballard Carbine,
.44 caliber, serial number 5105, 22" part- octagonal, part-round barrel. Top of the barrel stamped Worcester, Mass. Left flat stamped Merwin & Bray Agts, New York. Right flat stamped Ballard's Patent Nov. 5, 1861. Complete with two swivel rings. > Item Details
St. Etienne Model 1866 Bolt-Action Rifle and Smith Rubin Rifle,
Lot # 878 - St. Etienne Model 1866 Bolt-Action Rifle and Smith Rubin Rifle,
11mm caliber, 32.5" barrel, serial number14037 Receiver stamped Manufactured D'Arms St Etienne and stamped MLE 1866. French proof marks on barrel plus serial number. Second rifle 12mm, 33" barrel, serial number 178383. > Item Details
Marked George Kilbourn Civil War Era Drum
Lot # 239 - Marked George Kilbourn Civil War Era Drum
brown wood body with brass tacks forming geometric patterns. Eight brown leather tension braces (ears) affixed to ropes. Paper label on inside of drum reads Bass and Snare Drums Tambourines & Banjos Made and Repaired by George Kilbourn at His Premium Drum Factory 119 Orange Street Albany. Top and bo... > Item Details
Third Model Brown Bess, East India Company Musket,
Lot # 25 - Third Model Brown Bess, East India Company Musket,
Short-Land Pattern, .75 caliber, 35" barrel, flintlock, brass hardware, walnut stock. > Item Details
Framed U.S. <i>Maine</i> Brass Bunker Plate,
Lot # 885 - Framed U.S. Maine Brass Bunker Plate,
13.5" diameter brass plate with 1" square waffle grid. Attached paper label reads Bunker Plate from the USS Maine. This plate was used to sift the small pieces of coal from the large ones. This plate was given by the U.S. government to the Spanish American War encampment at Marion, Ohio. In 1960, wh... > Item Details
Civil War Shell Jacket,
Lot # 255 - Civil War Shell Jacket,
made of typical dark blue wool, partially hand-sewn, partially machined, trimmed with 3/8” red worsted tape per regulations. This specimen with ink stamped oval cartouche in left sleeve indicating manufacturer by the Schuylkill Arsenal. Jacket with compete but worn body lining consisting of course ... > Item Details
1839 US Belt, Buckle and Cap Box
Lot # 165 - 1839 US Belt, Buckle and Cap Box
leather belt with a cartouche on the back of belt in a circle stamped F.W. Chillingworth. The cap box has the same maker's mark on the inner flap. > Item Details
4835 Model 1860 Colt Army  Revolver,
Lot # 116 - 4835 Model 1860 Colt Army Revolver,
.44 caliber, serial number 39651, 8" barrel, with sub-inspector's markings. Grips marked Co. E. 8th Cav. Three screw frame. Cylinder stamped Colt's Patent 4368 with faint scene of Battle of Campeche. Mismatched serial numbers as follows; frame 39651, trigger guard 39363, and backstrap 39651. More... > Item Details
* 4865 US Model 1917 Eddystone  Bolt-Action Rifle With Bayonet,
Lot # 973 - * 4865 US Model 1917 Eddystone Bolt-Action Rifle With Bayonet,
.30 caliber, serial number 1220730, 26" barrel. Breech stamped U.S. Model of 1917 Eddystone. Left frame stamped RIA FK/S in a square, plus additional stampings of RA-P/AAS. Faint encircled cartouche behind trigger guard. Complete with two sling swivels and stacking swivel. PLUS, fullered bayonet s... > Item Details
L.C. Smith Shotgun,
Lot # 832 - L.C. Smith Shotgun,
12 gauge, 30" barrels, serial number 33293. Damascus finished barrels, case colored sidelocks and frame. Checkered buttstock and forend tip. Ebony tipped forearm. Finely figured buttstock and forearm. Very finely figured hard rubber buttplate. > Item Details
Mexican War Era Felt Tar Bucket Hat,
Lot # 36 - Mexican War Era Felt Tar Bucket Hat,
silver planchet with eagle bearing patriotic shield with arrows in its left talon and olive twigs in its right talon. Leather band encompasses the crown, with two piewheel vents immediately below flanking each side of hat. Double interlocking chains encompass front half of hat, with a leather band e... > Item Details
US Springfield Trapdoor Carbine,
Lot # 608 - US Springfield Trapdoor Carbine,
.45-70 caliber, 22" barrel, serial number 382139. Rifle rear sight. Stock has been decorated with brass tacks. 3/8" and .25" diameter tacks used for decoration. Tacks on right side of butt form a cross. Tacks on left side of butt form a circle. Two single lines of tacks running along each side of fo... > Item Details
Beaver Chapeau de Bras,
Lot # 29 - Beaver Chapeau de Bras,
ca 1821-1835. Black beaver body with black grosgrain rosette cockade on left side with brass eagle with a star on its right wing and a shield on its breast. Right talon clutching a paper scroll and left clutching arrows. Complete with a swag of undulating pattern black lace. Interior with black silk... > Item Details
4818 Springfield Model 1842 Percussion Musket,
Lot # 363 - 4818 Springfield Model 1842 Percussion Musket,
.69 caliber, 29.5" barrel, smoothbore. Steel hardware. Lockplate stamped Springfield 1850 with eagle carrying arrows and stamped U.S. on front of lockplate. Walnut stock. > Item Details
4822/4828 European Percussion Pistol and European Assembled Parts Flintlock Pistol,
Lot # 864 - 4822/4828 European Percussion Pistol and European Assembled Parts Flintlock Pistol,
European pistol .70 caliber, 10.25" barrel, walnut stock, brass hardware. Modern pistol .50 caliber, 6" barrel, patent breech, buckhorn rear sight, belt hooks, and walnut stock. > Item Details
ITEMS 1-20 of 20
SKIP TO PAGE: