Lot 701    

Display of Custer Little Big Horn Relics,
2006, Firearms and Early Militaria Auction, Dec 7
comprising an ummounted 2” x 3.25” albumen photograph of “Lt. Col. G.A. Custer” tipped to paper along with a purported silk “remnant” of 7th Cavalry colors and newspaper clipping referring to a “Mr. Schirmacher, one the heroes of the Yellowstone campaign under Custer,” and three spent .45-70 “brass shell casings” said to be relics from “the Custer battlefield at the Little Big Horn,” all mounted together under modern glass. With a photocopied notarized “Letter of Authenticity” given November 15, 2000 by a noted national dealer in Civil War militaria. The albumen is from the March 1876 series by photographer D.F. Barry (see Katz) showing Custer in the full dress uniform (helmet trimmed away) of his famous 7th Cavalry Regiment while the three .45-70s are correct cartridges for the issue Model 1873 Springfield trapdoor carbine with provenance not specified.

The section of silk bunting sits adjacent to a description that reads in full: Remnant of the only one of the colors of the 7th US cavalry saved from the Battle of the Little Big Horn, June 25, 1876 (picked up on the field). The accompanying “letter of authenticity” states that the fragment was at one time owned by the Goodspeed Book Shop at which time it was framed. It was originally owned by Pvt. Schirmacher, one of Colonel Custer’s troopers, referred to in the undated newspaper clipping. Despite the stated provenance the “flag remnant" could not possibly have been recovered from the Little Big Horn battlefield and is more likely a period piece of worn red/white/blue bunting imbued with late 19th century Custer mystique by Schirmacher, if indeed, we accept that he was the original owner. First and foremost, the remnant, roughly 3” x 5”, is made of thin silk, a material too fragile for field use, lightly machine stitched with a single strand of white cotton thread suitable only for a parade. Second, the precise details of both flags carried by the 7th Cavalry at the Little Big Horn are known and neither can physically match the cut and configuration of this purported narrow red/white/blue piece. The 7th Cavalry carried a regulation swallow-tail guidon made of heavy reinforced silk having a fly of red and white stripes with square blue union upper left containing two circular rows of 31 gold stars with four more stars at each corner. The second flag carried at Little Big Horn was Custer’s personal headquarters banner made by Libby Custer and it, too, was a swallow-tail design with equal horizontal stripes of red over blue with two large white crossed sabers in the center.

The regimental standard of the 7th Cavalry was not carried at the Little Big Horn while cavalry regiments were not authorized national colors—stars and stripes—until 1895. An examination of a photograph or diagram of a regulation cavalry guidon (which remained essentially unchanged from 1862 until 1885) it is evident that it is quite impossible to duplicate—even by selective cutting—the configuration of this remnant. It is speculative to suggest what Schirmacher’s symbolic remnant might be, but it is with a high degree of certainly not a relic of the 1876 Custer battlefield.

Provenance:  
Property of the former First National Bank of Fremont, Indiana


Condition:  
Silk and cartridges RELIC, heavily trimmed albumen VG.
Sold: $977.50
Price includes
Buyer's Premium
      Ask a Question

All Images

don't miss

an opportunity to bid. You can't win if you're not in.

sign up to bid

what's it worth?

ask the experts

sell your item

start selling
Confederate Cap Box
Lot # 215 - Confederate Cap Box
hand-sewn thick leather, pointed lead finial on bottom of box. Complete with original wool, caps, and vent pick. [See Pritchard, 2005: 70.] > Item Details
* Pair of Colt Centennial Miniature Pistols,
Lot # 953 - * Pair of Colt Centennial Miniature Pistols,
ca 1960's .22 caliber, 2.5" barrel, sequential serial numbers 45127d and 45128d. In original Colt case. > Item Details
U.S. Army Regulation M1853/55 Non-Rigid Knapsack,
Lot # 340 - U.S. Army Regulation M1853/55 Non-Rigid Knapsack,
that folded into a partial envelope and rear section made of four triangular flaps that buckled together, joined by a top strip with two sewn leather loops for the blanket straps. Knapsack was fitted with 2" wide leather shoulder straps that terminated with brass attachment points allowing for conn... > Item Details
American Rifleman's Knife & Scabbard,
Lot # 21 - American Rifleman's Knife & Scabbard,
17" spear point single-edged scalloped blade. Curved wood handle with six holes with three brass rivets, and one missing brass rivet. Complete with brass ricasso, hilt and quillon. Dark brown leather scabbard with brass throat stitching and belt loop attachment. > Item Details
U.S. Militaria Sword Belt Plate,
Lot # 206 - U.S. Militaria Sword Belt Plate,
ca 1812, 2.2" x 2.7". Die-stamped patriotic eagle. [See Kerksis, 1974: 175, fig. 169] > Item Details
Half-Stock Percussion Rifle,
Lot # 574 - Half-Stock Percussion Rifle,
.45 caliber, 31" octagonal barrel with patent breech. Back-action lock, walnut stock, and iron hardware. > Item Details
Two Issues of <i>The Journal of the Military Service Institution </i>, Autographed by Indian Wars Fighters,
Lot # 678 - Two Issues of The Journal of the Military Service Institution , Autographed by Indian Wars Fighters,
includes Vol. XIII(60),(1892)and Vol. XVI(75), (1895). The first autographed on the cover by James M. Ropes, the second by E.H. Liscum. Ropes began his military career with the 2nd U.S. Cavalry, serving in the Civil War. Afterwards, he served with the 8th U.S. Cavalry after the war until his retir... > Item Details
Pennsylvania Fireman Zouaves Belt, Buckle, and Cap Box
Lot # 176 - Pennsylvania Fireman Zouaves Belt, Buckle, and Cap Box
white buff leather belt with two-piece buckle that is the 1832-1860 type. Buckle marked P.F.Z. with laurel wreath encompassing the outer edge. Black leather cap box with small brass plate marked P.F.Z. The center of the plate is an eagle clenching olive twigs and arrows. [See O'Donnell, 1996: 231, ... > Item Details
Autographed Photograph of Benny Hodgson, KIA Little Big Horn,
Lot # 689 - Autographed Photograph of Benny Hodgson, KIA Little Big Horn,
Benjamin H. Hodgson (1848-1876) Second Lieutenant, 7th U.S. Cavalry. A fine autographed 4 x 5" image, mounted within a pale yellow border on a heavy large 4to album page; darkly, boldly signed B.H. Hodgson / Phila / Penna on mount just beneath the print. Image from an 1870 West Point class album. ... > Item Details
1851 Sword Belt with White Buff Leather and Hangers
Lot # 171 - 1851 Sword Belt with White Buff Leather and Hangers
Model 1851 buckle with a white buff leather belt and saber hangers. > Item Details
Early Sheffield Bowie Retailed By <i>Perraby & Hare, Hull</i>, England,
Lot # 421 - Early Sheffield Bowie Retailed By Perraby & Hare, Hull, England,
8.5" single-edged ridged clipped-point blade. Top of knife stamped in three lines C++X/Perraby & Hare/Hull. Stag-handled grip with iron ferrule and butt cap with ball finial. > Item Details
Civil War Housewife of Wm. Stephens, 4th O.V.I.,
Lot # 503 - Civil War Housewife of Wm. Stephens, 4th O.V.I.,
rolled brown calf leather on tin can base in which spools of thread were stored, interior with 2 pockets in silk and pads for needles, unrolled it is 11" x 4.5", closed it is 2" diameter with fabric pin cushion ends. Lot includes a photo copy of a collection registry of a Dr. Ross, reading in part N... > Item Details
M 1855 Sabre Bayonet
Lot # 480 - M 1855 Sabre Bayonet
brass handle saber bayonet with steel blade. Leather scabbard with brass fittings. Unmarked blade. Blade length is 21.75". Overall length is 16.75". Top of the brass handle stamped with a number 4. > Item Details
1839 Pistol Cartridge Box
Lot # 208 - 1839 Pistol Cartridge Box
with 1839 brass US plate on front flap. Second flap stamped A Dingee, New York. Interior complete with metal tins. > Item Details
Collection WWI German and Austrian Sleeve and Shoulder Patches
Lot # 917 - Collection WWI German and Austrian Sleeve and Shoulder Patches
32 sleeve and shoulder cloth insignia. Lot includes; 205 ordnance board, 39 board, five crowned artillery boards, 476 board, 466 board, 193 board, 39 board, 158 board, 13 artillery board, 2 board, MW VIII board, 618 board, 132 board, 51 ordnance board, 18 board, 416 cloth insignia, 416 cloth insign... > Item Details
218 <i>N.A. Smith</i> Philadelphia Medium Pocket Sized Percusion Pistol,
Lot # 139 - 218 N.A. Smith Philadelphia Medium Pocket Sized Percusion Pistol,
.50 caliber, 6.5" octagonal barrel stamped on top Philadelphia. Breech area with gold and platinum inlays. Engraved German silver back lockplate stamped N.A. Smith. Breech, tang, trigger guard, hammer and buttcap with period engravings. German silver front sight, as well as escutcheon, nosecap, inl... > Item Details
4783 Maynard Civil War Carbine, Second Model,
Lot # 379 - 4783 Maynard Civil War Carbine, Second Model,
.50 caliber, 20" round barrel with octagonal section at the breech. Left side of frame stamped Manufactured by Mass. Arms Co. Chicopee Falls, MA. Left side of frame stamped Edward Maynard Patent May 27, 1851/Dec. 6 1859. Walnut buttstock. > Item Details
Civil War Era Dress Epaulets of a Navy Captain In Original Tin Box,
Lot # 300 - Civil War Era Dress Epaulets of a Navy Captain In Original Tin Box,
silver bullion fouled anchor flanked by two silver bullion bars. Brass button with patriotic eagle clutching anchor, complete with pendant gold bullion coils. Underside with navy blue velvet and navy blue glazed cotton stamped Horstmann. PLUS, pair of Navy Lieutenant's Junior Grade silver bullion sh... > Item Details
Non Regulation Civil War Foot Officers Sword
Lot # 473 - Non Regulation Civil War Foot Officers Sword
manufactured by W Clauberg, Solingen. 33.5" blade etched on both sides U.S. and E. Pluribus Unum. Ornate iron guard and shagreen handles. Metal sheath > Item Details
7th Regiment NY Cartridge Belt and Shoulder Strap
Lot # 223 - 7th Regiment NY Cartridge Belt and Shoulder Strap
buff white shoulder strap, NG 7th regiment brass plate on front of cartridge box. ID'd to soldier named Arnold inked on inside flap. > Item Details
ITEMS 1-20 of 20
SKIP TO PAGE: