Lot 15    

Graphic CDV of Military Execution
2010, American History, Including the Civil War
Likely unpublished and rare, no backmark, captioned “The Deserters Fate” in symbolic red ink beneath dead soldier propped against a crude coffin. A disturbing photograph framing the corpse of a freshly executed boy-soldier in the foreground. Twenty paces distance from the unknown victim is the firing squad consisting of 14 armed men commanded by a sergeant — all appearing unfazed by the notoriety. The location is likewise unknown, but irregular patches of a lighter color amidst the bramble of dry grass suggest either melting snow or sand. The dead boy — displaying an illegible placard? — has been shot multiple times in the lower face, the blindfold removed and lying on the coffin revealing vacant eyes.

Robert I. Alotta’s Civil War Justice-Union Army Executions under Lincoln (1989), cites 276 military executions during the Civil War, 186 by firing squad and 90 by hanging. Multiple desertion was the leading cause with 147 soldiers formally executed in the name of deterrence.

This never-before-seen cdv bears some striking similarities to a pencil-and-chalk drawing of an early military execution that appeared in Harper’s Weekly on December 13, 1861. The scene in Virginia by artist Alfred Wordsworth Thompson captured the execution of Private William H. Johnston, Company D., 1st New York Cavalry who was illustrated wearing a light-colored shirt without military jacket. Johnston, who had been “singled out for very special treatment,” was the first Union soldier formally charged with desertion, and, as such, the court-martial proceeding received special attention from the Adjutant General and War Department. Alotta wrote that “(Johnston’s) trial and execution became a model for those that followed throughout the Civil War.”

In blatant juxtaposition to Victorian sensibilities, the anonymous photographer recorded the grisly aftermath of the sentence in detail still repellant — the Deserter’s Fate.


Condition:  
Sepia albumen with strong clarity. Mount is soiled with light wear and dented corners.
Sold: $2,467.50
Price includes
Buyer's Premium
      Ask a Question

All Images

don't miss

an opportunity to bid. You can't win if you're not in.

sign up to bid

what's it worth?

ask the experts

sell your item

start selling
Plate Believed to be From First Lincoln White House Service
Lot # 297 - Plate Believed to be From First Lincoln White House Service
French, ca 1861. A Haviland, Limoges plate believed to be from the state service made for President Abraham Lincoln. The center printed and painted with a brown eagle clasping a laurel branch and a cluster of arrows in his talons. With royal purple rim edged with a border of gilt dots and "Alhambra"... > Item Details
Zachary Taylor Indian Peace Medal, 1849
Lot # 279 - Zachary Taylor Indian Peace Medal, 1849
Bronze or bronzed copper medal. The obverse features a bust portrait of Zachary Taylor and reads Zachary Taylor President of the United States 1849; the reverse features a crossed tomahawk and peace pipe placed over clasped hands, and reads Peace and Friendship, with the index finger pointing to the... > Item Details
Thomas Jefferson Carved Folk Art Cane
Lot # 275 - Thomas Jefferson Carved Folk Art Cane
third quarter 19th century. With relief carved banner spiraling around shaft: Thomas Jefferson of VA Born April 13, 1743, Was President USA 1801 to 1809 Wrote Declaration of Independence Found Of University VA 1819 Died At Monticello 1820 This Cane Was Cut Near Jefferson's Tomb Monticello VA. Shaft... > Item Details
Signed D.F. Barry and Rain-In-The-Face Photograph
Lot # 409 - Signed D.F. Barry and Rain-In-The-Face Photograph
Silver gelatin portrait of Barry and Rain-in-the-face, with their names stamped below the image; both photograph and mount include Barry's blindstamp; with following verso manuscript: Sept. 30th 190(?) Superior, Wis / To / Albert F. Dodd. / With Compliments, and best wishes / of D.F. Barry. 6.25 x 8... > Item Details
Edward Curtis Signed Silver Print, <i>Water Carriers</i>
Lot # 523 - Edward Curtis Signed Silver Print, Water Carriers
A Curtis silver print, unmarked, but titled Water Carriers, from the North American Indian; v.12; plate 435; signed by Curtis in lower right corner of print, on woven paper, 13.75 x 17.25 in., mounted, 18 x 22 in. AUCTIONEER'S NOTE: This was originally cataloged as a photogravure, when in fact, it i... > Item Details
Mary Harlan Lincoln & Father, Judge James Harlan, Photographs
Lot # 318 - Mary Harlan Lincoln & Father, Judge James Harlan, Photographs
Lot of 6 photographs, including the following: a cdv-sized photograph that has been lightly hand-colored, signed Mary Harlan below portrait, 2 x 3.25 in, matted and framed, 3.5 x 5.5 in.; 2 albumen photographs of Mary and Robert Todd Lincoln's oldest daughter, Mamie, from the same sitting, 1 measure... > Item Details
Alexander Gardner Stereoviews of the Dead at Gettysburg
Lot # 39 - Alexander Gardner Stereoviews of the Dead at Gettysburg
Lot of 8, each on yellow square corner mounts with 1863 copyright line on recto, with applied paper printed labels from Gardner's Photographic Incidents of the War series on verso, title: No. 229/All Over Now-Confederate Sharp-shooter At Foot Of Round Top, Gettysburg; No. 234/Federal Soldiers As The... > Item Details
Brigadier General Samuel M. Whitside Signed Photograph
Lot # 488 - Brigadier General Samuel M. Whitside Signed Photograph
Ca late 1880s. 3.25 x 5 in. photo (a bit larger than a standard cdv) inscribed and signed S.M. Whitside U.S.A, with backmark of Williams & Thomson, Kansas City, MO. Samuel Marmaduke Whitside was born in 1839 in Toronto, Canada. He enlisted as a private in New York City in 1858 and assigned to the 6t... > Item Details
Zachary Taylor, Document Signed
Lot # 226 - Zachary Taylor, Document Signed
Taylor, Zachary (1784-1850). Twelfth President of the United States (1849-1850). 1p, document signed at Fort Crawford, Michigan Territory (present-day Wisconsin), February 1833. The document is a requisition for fuel by Col. Taylor for himself and two servants. Col. Taylor was stationed in Fort... > Item Details
Collection of Photographic Medals Awarded to Jeanie A. Welford
Lot # 271 - Collection of Photographic Medals Awarded to Jeanie A. Welford
Lot of 17 photographic medals, including 9 that were awarded to the female photographer Jeanie A. Welford (1855-1949), wife of well-known photo journalist W.D. Welford (d. 1919), both from England. W.D. Welford wrote many articles on photography, dealing with topics such as the use of toning solutio... > Item Details
Rare Sitting Bull Stereoview by S.J. Morrow
Lot # 419 - Rare Sitting Bull Stereoview by S.J. Morrow
On Morrow's grey, cabinet mount stock with his Yankton, D.T. imprint. Morrow probably copied this image from O.S. Goff not long after sitting Bull's surrender and arrival at Fort Randall in 1882. Sitting Bull appears here in this rare pose, defiant, gazing into the distance. > Item Details
U.S. Civil War Model 1855 Bayonet with Type II Scabbard
Lot # 166 - U.S. Civil War Model 1855 Bayonet with Type II Scabbard
18" blade with U.S. and with inspector's initials. Nice leather Type II scabbard with brass fittings. > Item Details
Brady Negatives of W.T. Sherman and Other Military Figures
Lot # 260 - Brady Negatives of W.T. Sherman and Other Military Figures
Lot of 6 collodion negatives of military figures produced by Mathew Brady, including the following: two negatives, each with 2 half-plate exposures of General W.T. Sherman (1820-1891), photographs taken ca 1876-1883; 1 whole-plate exposure and 2 half-plate exposures on same plate of Admiral David Po... > Item Details
Cabinet Card of <i>Comanche</i>, Sole Survivor of the Custer Massacre
Lot # 461 - Cabinet Card of Comanche, Sole Survivor of the Custer Massacre
Albumen photograph on cream mount, not credited, but an image taken by O.S. Goff in the aftermath of the Little Big Horn for a public that could not learn enough about the massacre. As Myles Keogh's mount, Commanche was never ridden again, and lived for 14 years after the battle, costing the Govern... > Item Details
Model 1850 Foot Officer's Sword
Lot # 150 - Model 1850 Foot Officer's Sword
32" blade etched with military motifs. Shagreen and brass wire-wrapped handle. Leather scabbard with brass bands and carrying rings. > Item Details
J.J. Wall Photographs of Western Figures at Camp
Lot # 510 - J.J. Wall Photographs of Western Figures at Camp
Lot of silver gelatin silver prints, ca 1880s-90s, 4.5 x 6.75 in. on 7.25 x 9.25 in. mounts imprinted J.J. Wall, Gross, Nebraska below image. One photo shows a group of 15 men, some with visible sidearms and one armed with a lever-action rifle, congregated outside a tent marked Dr. Hand, with bottl... > Item Details
Early Maps of Tennessee and North Carolina
Lot # 346 - Early Maps of Tennessee and North Carolina
Lot of 2. A New and Accurate Map of North Carolina in North America. London: J. Hinton, 1779. From The Universal Magazine, Oct. 1779. 10.75 x 14 in. (sight), matted and framed. Appears to be lightly toned. Tanner, Benjamin (after Daniel Smith) A Map of the Tennassee Government formerly Part of North... > Item Details
Rare John Adams / Thomas Jefferson Memorial Ribbon
Lot # 274 - Rare John Adams / Thomas Jefferson Memorial Ribbon
A silk memorial ribbon featuring busts of John Adams and Thomas Jefferson framed within a wreath, with their names, birth dates, and Died July 4, 1826 printed below the portraits, approx. 1.5 x 9.75 in. On July 4, 1826, fifty years to the day after the adoption of the Declaration of Independence, Ad... > Item Details
Portrait of Lincoln by Frank R. Harper, Oil on Canvas
Lot # 286 - Portrait of Lincoln by Frank R. Harper, Oil on Canvas
Frank Robert Harper (American, 1876-1948), titled Lincoln Series "Emancipation" on verso, signed l.l.; 24.5 x 17.5 in. > Item Details
African American Private Marcus Harvey, 28th Indiana USCT, Tintype Collection
Lot # 80 - African American Private Marcus Harvey, 28th Indiana USCT, Tintype Collection
Lot of 4 items related to Private Marcus Harvey of the 28th Indiana USCT, Company B, including the following: full plate tintype of a young Marcus Harvey in plain clothes; a full plate tintype of Marcus Harvey in uniform, wearing a 9-button sack coat and kepi, armed with a rifle, and standing with a... > Item Details
ITEMS 1-20 of 20
SKIP TO PAGE: