Lot 15    

Graphic CDV of Military Execution
2010, American History, Including the Civil War
Likely unpublished and rare, no backmark, captioned “The Deserters Fate” in symbolic red ink beneath dead soldier propped against a crude coffin. A disturbing photograph framing the corpse of a freshly executed boy-soldier in the foreground. Twenty paces distance from the unknown victim is the firing squad consisting of 14 armed men commanded by a sergeant — all appearing unfazed by the notoriety. The location is likewise unknown, but irregular patches of a lighter color amidst the bramble of dry grass suggest either melting snow or sand. The dead boy — displaying an illegible placard? — has been shot multiple times in the lower face, the blindfold removed and lying on the coffin revealing vacant eyes.

Robert I. Alotta’s Civil War Justice-Union Army Executions under Lincoln (1989), cites 276 military executions during the Civil War, 186 by firing squad and 90 by hanging. Multiple desertion was the leading cause with 147 soldiers formally executed in the name of deterrence.

This never-before-seen cdv bears some striking similarities to a pencil-and-chalk drawing of an early military execution that appeared in Harper’s Weekly on December 13, 1861. The scene in Virginia by artist Alfred Wordsworth Thompson captured the execution of Private William H. Johnston, Company D., 1st New York Cavalry who was illustrated wearing a light-colored shirt without military jacket. Johnston, who had been “singled out for very special treatment,” was the first Union soldier formally charged with desertion, and, as such, the court-martial proceeding received special attention from the Adjutant General and War Department. Alotta wrote that “(Johnston’s) trial and execution became a model for those that followed throughout the Civil War.”

In blatant juxtaposition to Victorian sensibilities, the anonymous photographer recorded the grisly aftermath of the sentence in detail still repellant — the Deserter’s Fate.


Condition:  
Sepia albumen with strong clarity. Mount is soiled with light wear and dented corners.
Sold: $2,467.50
Price includes
Buyer's Premium
      Ask a Question

All Images

<i>Buffalo Bill's Wild West</i> Souvenir Photographs
Lot # 515 - Buffalo Bill's Wild West Souvenir Photographs
Buffalo Bill's Wild West Show made its first major international trip, complete with over 200 performers (including 97 Indians), 180 horses, and 18 buffalo, to Manchester, England in November 1887. The show was a sensation, selling out its custom built 10,000 seat arena almost nightly for five mont... > Item Details
<i>1840</i> Hand-painted Flag with Eagle, Purportedly Flown at Sutter's Fort
Lot # 190 - 1840 Hand-painted Flag with Eagle, Purportedly Flown at Sutter's Fort
Approx. 74 x 132 in. with 5 red and 5 white stripes. White fabric is cotton, red is wool. Pieced with a mixture of hand and machine stitching. Hand-painted on the white canton is an eagle with an arc of 13 blue stars above (3-7-3), shield on breast, branch and arrows in talons. 1840 painted below. A... > Item Details
De Lancey Gill Photograph of <i>Peter Tall Mandan</i>, Brule Sioux
Lot # 384 - De Lancey Gill Photograph of Peter Tall Mandan, Brule Sioux
Platinum print produced by De Lancey W. Gill, of the Bureau of American Ethnology, Smithsonian Institution, identified in pencil on verso as Peter Tall Mandan - Brule Sioux, and numbered 6684, with photographer's stamp lower left, 1913, photograph 6 x 7 in., overall 8 x 10 in. A fine profile portrai... > Item Details
Watkins' Photo <i>View on the Merced River, Yosemite</i>
Lot # 519 - Watkins' Photo View on the Merced River, Yosemite
8 x 12 in. albumen print with Watkins' San Francisco imprint. Distributed Compliments of Fireman's Fund Insurance Co. of Cal. for the U.S. Centennial with A Happy New Year 1876 at top center. Currently framed to 18 x 20 in. and glazed. > Item Details
Zachary Taylor Indian Peace Medal, 1849
Lot # 279 - Zachary Taylor Indian Peace Medal, 1849
Bronze or bronzed copper medal. The obverse features a bust portrait of Zachary Taylor and reads Zachary Taylor President of the United States 1849; the reverse features a crossed tomahawk and peace pipe placed over clasped hands, and reads Peace and Friendship, with the index finger pointing to the... > Item Details
Richard Throssel Photograph of <i>Two Moons - The Cheyenne</i>
Lot # 541 - Richard Throssel Photograph of Two Moons - The Cheyenne
Silver print with embossed arrowhead seal, copyrighted 1907 and negative number 6917 lower left of print, 6.5 x 8.5 in. (sight), archivally matted and framed, 13.5 x 16.75 in. Two Moons was present at the Little Big Horn, and was one of three models making up the composite image for the Indian Head ... > Item Details
Edward Curtis Portfolio Photogravure, <i>At the Gateway - Acoma</i>
Lot # 526 - Edward Curtis Portfolio Photogravure, At the Gateway - Acoma
From The North American Indian; v.16; plate 568; on Van Gelder paper, 1904, folio, 11.5 x 15.5 in., matted and framed, 24 x 28 in. > Item Details
U.S. Civil War Pattern of 1857 Rifled-Musket Cartridge Box with Straps and Bull'seye Canteen
Lot # 182 - U.S. Civil War Pattern of 1857 Rifled-Musket Cartridge Box with Straps and Bull'seye Canteen
Army cartridge box with brass plate stamped SNY. Cartridge box with maker's mark J.E. Condict. Interior of box compete with tins. > Item Details
John C.H. Grabill Photograph of Deadwood
Lot # 492 - John C.H. Grabill Photograph of Deadwood
Ca 1888 imperial albumen photograph, 6.5 x 8.75 in., on a 7 x 10 in. cream mount with gold beveled edges and Grabill's Deadwood and Sturgis, Dakota Ter. imprint, captioned on negative Deadwood from Engle side, Copyright 1888 by Grabill, with Grabill's backmark advertising Colorado, Wyoming and Dakot... > Item Details
Buehman  Stereoview of Apache Scout Medal of Honor Winner
Lot # 395 - Buehman Stereoview of Apache Scout Medal of Honor Winner
Yellow cabinet-sized mount, with inked inscription Nan-tag-isra. (Scout) on verso. A fine view of Nantaje or Nantahe, holding a Springfield rifle. He served with Crook during the Yavapai campaign of 1872-73 and along with nine other Apache scouts was awarded the Congressional Medal of Honor in 1875... > Item Details
19th Century Horn Cup with Engraved Plaque Attributing Ownership to Duke of Wellington
Lot # 366 - 19th Century Horn Cup with Engraved Plaque Attributing Ownership to Duke of Wellington
4.5 in. tall, approx. 2 in. diam. at bottom, 3 in. at top, with engraved silver plaque reading This Cup was used by the Duke of Wellington at the Battle of Waterloo June 1815. It was the property of General Nelson who was in the Duke's mess, and who presented it to his brother-in-law Commodore Wats... > Item Details
Lane Photographs of Fort Buford, North Dakota
Lot # 491 - Lane Photographs of Fort Buford, North Dakota
Lot of 2 ca 1890s gelatin silver images, 7.25 x 8.75 in., on brown 8 x 10 in. mounts with gold beveled edges and Lane's Fargo, N.D. imprint, one showing soldiers being drilled near the fort, one showing about 100 soldiers marching in a thin column across the plains. > Item Details
Brigadier General Samuel M. Whitside Signed Photograph
Lot # 488 - Brigadier General Samuel M. Whitside Signed Photograph
Ca late 1880s. 3.25 x 5 in. photo (a bit larger than a standard cdv) inscribed and signed S.M. Whitside U.S.A, with backmark of Williams & Thomson, Kansas City, MO. Samuel Marmaduke Whitside was born in 1839 in Toronto, Canada. He enlisted as a private in New York City in 1858 and assigned to the 6t... > Item Details
Nez Perce Pennant Presented to Brig. Gen. O.O. Howard
Lot # 484 - Nez Perce Pennant Presented to Brig. Gen. O.O. Howard
Red campaign streamer with two black stripes, 2.75 x 47 in. with swallow-tail fly, single grommet in hoist. Embroidered in gold NEZ PERCES 1877. Currently framed to 7.25 x 50.75 in. Typed label taped to back notes that this was Presented to Brig. Gen. O.O. Howard after the Nez Perce war of 1877. Oli... > Item Details
Edward Curtis Photogravure, <i>Elk Head and Sacred Pipe Bundle</i>
Lot # 529 - Edward Curtis Photogravure, Elk Head and Sacred Pipe Bundle
Volume photogravure printed on Van Gelder paper, dated 1907, 5.25 x 7.25 in., matted and framed, 11.5 x 14.5 in. > Item Details
Silver Thimble and Embroidered Heart Pincushion Descended Directly in the Lincoln Family
Lot # 317 - Silver Thimble and Embroidered Heart Pincushion Descended Directly in the Lincoln Family
Lot of 2, including silver thimble that purportedly belonged to Mary Todd Lincoln, 1 in. ht; and 1 heart-shaped pincushion embroidered with green leaves and red berries, 3.5 in. x 4 in. Property of the Heir of Robert Todd Lincoln Beckwith (1904-1985) and Margaret Fristoe (1901-2009) The following l... > Item Details
L.A. Huffman Photograph, <i>Working a Little Bunch in the Hills</i>
Lot # 503 - L.A. Huffman Photograph, Working a Little Bunch in the Hills
Silver gelatin photograph by L.A. Huffman titled Working a Little Bunch in the Hills, incorrectly labeled lower left, 5 x 7.75 in., mounted on board, 6 x 10.75 in., with another image mounted to board's verso. > Item Details
Hannibal Hamlin's U.S. Senatorial Chair
Lot # 282 - Hannibal Hamlin's U.S. Senatorial Chair
One of three known to exist, a United States Senate Chamber's armchair, 1819, attributed to the workshop of New York cabinetmaker, Thomas Constantine (b.1763- d.1844), and made of mahogany and mahogany veneers, with maple, H. 38.375 in., W. 23.25 in., D. 19.5 in. Hannibal Hamlin, (b. August 2... > Item Details
Civil War Photograph of Officers from the 44th NY Vols., <i>Ellsworth's Avengers</i>
Lot # 29 - Civil War Photograph of Officers from the 44th NY Vols., Ellsworth's Avengers
Albumen photograph, 6 x 8.25 in. with clipped corners, on a mount trimmed to the same size with printed label of Churchill & Denison of Albany, New York, and two five-cent revenue stamps, dated in ink Oct 14, 1864, applied to verso. The 44th NY Vols., or "Ellsworth's Avengers," were so called as the... > Item Details
General Samuel D. Sturgis ALS, 1874
Lot # 466 - General Samuel D. Sturgis ALS, 1874
2pp, on 7.75 x 10 in. 7th Cavalry letterhead, St. Paul, MN, 20 Aug. 1874. To John Beatty [Genl.], S.D. Myers (?), and Wm. McCrory [Capt.] of the Executive Committee of the Society of the Army of the Cumberland. Expressing regrets that because of a general court-martial scheduled for the same time at... > Item Details
ITEMS 1-20 of 20
SKIP TO PAGE: