Lot 15    

Graphic CDV of Military Execution
2010, American History, Including the Civil War
Likely unpublished and rare, no backmark, captioned “The Deserters Fate” in symbolic red ink beneath dead soldier propped against a crude coffin. A disturbing photograph framing the corpse of a freshly executed boy-soldier in the foreground. Twenty paces distance from the unknown victim is the firing squad consisting of 14 armed men commanded by a sergeant — all appearing unfazed by the notoriety. The location is likewise unknown, but irregular patches of a lighter color amidst the bramble of dry grass suggest either melting snow or sand. The dead boy — displaying an illegible placard? — has been shot multiple times in the lower face, the blindfold removed and lying on the coffin revealing vacant eyes.

Robert I. Alotta’s Civil War Justice-Union Army Executions under Lincoln (1989), cites 276 military executions during the Civil War, 186 by firing squad and 90 by hanging. Multiple desertion was the leading cause with 147 soldiers formally executed in the name of deterrence.

This never-before-seen cdv bears some striking similarities to a pencil-and-chalk drawing of an early military execution that appeared in Harper’s Weekly on December 13, 1861. The scene in Virginia by artist Alfred Wordsworth Thompson captured the execution of Private William H. Johnston, Company D., 1st New York Cavalry who was illustrated wearing a light-colored shirt without military jacket. Johnston, who had been “singled out for very special treatment,” was the first Union soldier formally charged with desertion, and, as such, the court-martial proceeding received special attention from the Adjutant General and War Department. Alotta wrote that “(Johnston’s) trial and execution became a model for those that followed throughout the Civil War.”

In blatant juxtaposition to Victorian sensibilities, the anonymous photographer recorded the grisly aftermath of the sentence in detail still repellant — the Deserter’s Fate.


Condition:  
Sepia albumen with strong clarity. Mount is soiled with light wear and dented corners.
Sold: $2,467.50
Price includes
Buyer's Premium
      Ask a Question

All Images

don't miss

an opportunity to bid. You can't win if you're not in.

sign up to bid

what's it worth?

ask the experts

sell your item

start selling
CSA Captain Walter Bowie Post-War Photograph by Miley
Lot # 33 - CSA Captain Walter Bowie Post-War Photograph by Miley
Lot includes photograph and related photocopies of documents. Large format albumen mounted on 8 x 10 in. card. Studio image of Bowie in a 3-piece suit and narrow bow tie, a style typical of the last quarter of the century; with Michael Miley's blindstamp lower left of image. On verso is penciled gen... > Item Details
Starr Single Action  Army Revolver
Lot # 115 - Starr Single Action Army Revolver
.44 caliber, 8" round barrel; S/N 30117. One-piece wood grips. > Item Details
Alexander Gardner Stereoviews of Refugee Slaves
Lot # 65 - Alexander Gardner Stereoviews of Refugee Slaves
Lot of 2, both on yellow square-cornered mounts, including one with an applied paper printed label on verso from Gardner's Photographic Incidents of the War series, titled No. 519/Fugitive Negroes Crossing Rappahannock During Pope's Retreat, with an abridged version of the title on an inked manuscri... > Item Details
Edward Curtis Collection of Northwest and Southwest Indian Photogravures
Lot # 522 - Edward Curtis Collection of Northwest and Southwest Indian Photogravures
Lot of 6 Edward Curtis photogravures, including the following: A Capitan Grande Man - Diegueno, 1924; A Santa Ysabel Man - Diegueno, 1924; A Mesa Grande Man - Diegueno, 1924; and Su - Donii ("Osier-Willow Blossom") - Pyramid Lake Paviotso, 1924, each printed on Japan Vellum; plus Silto - Quilliute, ... > Item Details
Gwyn & Campbell Civil War Percussion Carbine
Lot # 122 - Gwyn & Campbell Civil War Percussion Carbine
.52 caliber, 20" octagonal-to-round barrel; S/N 3261. Lock marked Gwyn & Campbell, Hamilton Ohio; right side of frame marked Union Rifle, Type 11. Walnut stock. > Item Details
Fine Group of African American-Related Real Photo Postcards
Lot # 204 - Fine Group of African American-Related Real Photo Postcards
Lot of 3 real photo postcards with African American subject matter, including the following titles written in the negatives: Cotton Picking, by E.C. Eddy, South Pines, NC; Baptism, New Bern, NC; and Sheridan Home School, a group portrait of a class of African American students with their teacher tak... > Item Details
Alexander Gardner Stereoviews of Confederate Dead near Spotsylvania Court House
Lot # 41 - Alexander Gardner Stereoviews of Confederate Dead near Spotsylvania Court House
Lot of 3, each on cream square corner mounts with Gardner's 1863 copyright line on recto, unnumbered and untitled, but known to be Confederate dead laid out for burial at Mrs. Alsop's Pine Forest, May 20, 1864, three miles from Spotsylvania Court House, Virginia and two different views of Confederat... > Item Details
Civil War Recommendation Endorsed by Genls. Wadsorth, DOW at Wilderness, Paul, WIA at Gettysburg, & Patrick
Lot # 96 - Civil War Recommendation Endorsed by Genls. Wadsorth, DOW at Wilderness, Paul, WIA at Gettysburg, & Patrick
1p, 8 x 10 in. blue lined paper, dated HdQrs 35th NY Vols, Camp near Belle Landing, Va., Dec 23, 1862 recommending Maj. John G. Todd be commissioned a Lieutenant Colonel, endorsed by Brig. Gen. James Wadsworth (1807-1864), the military governor of the District of Columbia and unsuccessful Republican... > Item Details
Half Plate Tintype of Federal Officer Presenting Sword
Lot # 9 - Half Plate Tintype of Federal Officer Presenting Sword
A fine portrait of an unidentified captain with stylish chin whiskers holding a silver-hilted presentation sword for the camera. He wears a standard nine-button frock coat casually unbuttoned and officer’s slouch hat with cords. His sash is lightly washed in red. > Item Details
Group Portrait Featuring Captain Jack Crawford
Lot # 516 - Group Portrait Featuring Captain Jack Crawford
Albumen, 10 x 19 in., ca late 19th century. Group of 29 men, all but Jack in suits (most with vests, watch chains, mustaches). In center are two men in uniforms that we are sure someone will recognize (railroad?) > Item Details
Civil War Request for Reassignment Docketed by Brig. Gen. Henry Baxter, WIA at Antietam, Fredericksburg, & Wilderness
Lot # 92 - Civil War Request for Reassignment Docketed by Brig. Gen. Henry Baxter, WIA at Antietam, Fredericksburg, & Wilderness
2pp, approx. 8 x 10 in., Pittsburgh, PA, 8 Sept. 1864. Letter signed by Capt. John B. McGrew, 11th Regt. PA Vols. to the CO of the unit. McGrew notes that he enlisted Cornelius Sullivan on 4 May 1864 for Co. G. However, a letter received by his friend indicated that he was sent to the 1st Regt. PA R... > Item Details
Robert Browning Signed Photograph
Lot # 238 - Robert Browning Signed Photograph
Mounted on 7.5 x 10 in. card. Lower margin with inscription: Mrs. Smalley with the best regards of Robert Browning June 21, '83. Robert Browning (1812-1889) was an English poet and playwright. Though not particularly successful in either his plays or prose, he developed techniques, such as his use ... > Item Details
[NEW ORLEANS] <i>Coast-Directory</i> by Charles J. Pike, 1847
Lot # 347 - [NEW ORLEANS] Coast-Directory by Charles J. Pike, 1847
"Ribbon" map, 8.5 x 81 in. on linen, wood roller on one end, wood moulding strip on other for hanging. The map extends from New Orleans in the south, up river through Baton Rouge to Port Hudson. Along the banks are noted land owners and businesses, such as Louisiana Sugar Refinery, glassworks, a saw... > Item Details
William H. Jackson CDV of <i>Omahaw</i> Chiefs
Lot # 407 - William H. Jackson CDV of Omahaw Chiefs
Albumen cdv of five Omaha Chiefs in mixed traditional and western clothing, labeled in ink as Omahaw across top of image, with Jackson Bros., Omaha, Neb. backmark, ca 1868. > Item Details
L.A. Huffman CDV of Interior of <i>Delmonico Dining Hall</i>, Miles City, Montana
Lot # 502 - L.A. Huffman CDV of Interior of Delmonico Dining Hall, Miles City, Montana
Ca late 1870s-1880s, with Huffman's imprint on verso, with R.M. Dryden Prop. and the address of the hotel on recto. An exceptional interior image of the dining room and its staff, decorated with American flags, a sign reading Chequamegan visible over a passageway. A rare image. > Item Details
Chief Joseph Signature
Lot # 472 - Chief Joseph Signature
In top margin of lined paper with typed note about Joseph. Framed with copy photograph of Joseph with a Carlisle student, Stephen Reuben and Peo-peo-talaket. Many Native Americans in the late 19th century learned to write their names and even read a bit, often in their later years once they were con... > Item Details
Civil War Diary of Capt. Llewellyn J. Blanchard, Co. E, 5th Michigan Infantry
Lot # 84 - Civil War Diary of Capt. Llewellyn J. Blanchard, Co. E, 5th Michigan Infantry
Lot includes diary and copies of related paperwork. Originally a member of the famed 2nd U.S. Sharpshooters Regiment, a regiment raised mostly in Michigan, Llewellyn Blanchard transferred near the end of the Civil War, accepting a commission as Capt. of Co. E, 5th Michigan Infantry. He joined his n... > Item Details
Scarce Photograph of Western Surveyor, Francis Vinton Greene
Lot # 375 - Scarce Photograph of Western Surveyor, Francis Vinton Greene
Lot of 2, one cdv and one cabinet card. Both taken at the same time, with imprint of Charles A. Zimmerman, St. Paul, MN. In the cabinet photo Greene is wearing cold-weather gear, a knit hat and scarf, and Cree fringed leather jacket, pants and embroidered fur mittens. The footwear is also Cree in de... > Item Details
<i>Tom. Ute Warrior</i> Photograph by Charles M.  Bell
Lot # 380 - Tom. Ute Warrior Photograph by Charles M. Bell
9.5 x 14 in. (sight), 18.25 x 22.25 in. with frame. Taken between Jan. 2 and 16, 1879. Captain Tom was a member of a small delegation of Utes which came to Washington, D.C. to discuss changing the locality of their reservation in Colorado. They arrived on January 2, 1879. On January 13, Captain ... > Item Details
F.J. Haynes Cabinet Photograph of Crow Brave Big Medicine Man & Squaw
Lot # 415 - F.J. Haynes Cabinet Photograph of Crow Brave Big Medicine Man & Squaw
Ca 1885 albumen cabinet photo on a light gray mount with Haynes' Fargo, D.T. imprint on verso. No title or id is present, but this is known to be a photograph of Big Medicine Man, a Crow brave who would later serve as Chief of Police at Crow Agency, Montana, and his wife. The fan and beadwork piec... > Item Details
ITEMS 1-20 of 20
SKIP TO PAGE: