Lot 15    

Graphic CDV of Military Execution
2010, American History, Including the Civil War
Likely unpublished and rare, no backmark, captioned “The Deserters Fate” in symbolic red ink beneath dead soldier propped against a crude coffin. A disturbing photograph framing the corpse of a freshly executed boy-soldier in the foreground. Twenty paces distance from the unknown victim is the firing squad consisting of 14 armed men commanded by a sergeant — all appearing unfazed by the notoriety. The location is likewise unknown, but irregular patches of a lighter color amidst the bramble of dry grass suggest either melting snow or sand. The dead boy — displaying an illegible placard? — has been shot multiple times in the lower face, the blindfold removed and lying on the coffin revealing vacant eyes.

Robert I. Alotta’s Civil War Justice-Union Army Executions under Lincoln (1989), cites 276 military executions during the Civil War, 186 by firing squad and 90 by hanging. Multiple desertion was the leading cause with 147 soldiers formally executed in the name of deterrence.

This never-before-seen cdv bears some striking similarities to a pencil-and-chalk drawing of an early military execution that appeared in Harper’s Weekly on December 13, 1861. The scene in Virginia by artist Alfred Wordsworth Thompson captured the execution of Private William H. Johnston, Company D., 1st New York Cavalry who was illustrated wearing a light-colored shirt without military jacket. Johnston, who had been “singled out for very special treatment,” was the first Union soldier formally charged with desertion, and, as such, the court-martial proceeding received special attention from the Adjutant General and War Department. Alotta wrote that “(Johnston’s) trial and execution became a model for those that followed throughout the Civil War.”

In blatant juxtaposition to Victorian sensibilities, the anonymous photographer recorded the grisly aftermath of the sentence in detail still repellant — the Deserter’s Fate.


Condition:  
Sepia albumen with strong clarity. Mount is soiled with light wear and dented corners.
Sold: $2,467.50
Price includes
Buyer's Premium
      Ask a Question

All Images

don't miss

an opportunity to bid. You can't win if you're not in.

sign up to bid

what's it worth?

ask the experts

sell your item

start selling
D. F. Barry Cabinet Photograph of <i>Brave Bear</i>, Hunkpapa Sioux Chief
Lot # 411 - D. F. Barry Cabinet Photograph of Brave Bear, Hunkpapa Sioux Chief
ca 1880s albumen photograph on a navy blue card with gilt beveled edges, Barry's Bismarck, Dakota Territory imprint, with applied paper printed label Brave Bear, and ink inscription Oncapapa Sioux Chief on image, verso applied with printed paper label from the Second International Congress of Eugeni... > Item Details
Patrick Henry, First Governor of Virginia, DS
Lot # 220 - Patrick Henry, First Governor of Virginia, DS
Commission for Henry Tazewell to be Captain of a Troop of Horse (Cavalry), 4 Sept. 1777, and signed P. Henry as Governor of the Commonwealth of Virginia (1776-1779, 1784-1786. 5.25 x 8.75 in. framed with a lithograph of Henry. Although some of the better known quotes attributed to Henry have been qu... > Item Details
Alexander Gardner Stereoviews of <i>Officers on Board the Monitor</i>
Lot # 64 - Alexander Gardner Stereoviews of Officers on Board the Monitor
On a yellow square-cornered mount, with 1862 copyright line and applied paper label ink inscribed Officers on the Monitor July 9th 1862 on recto, from Gardner's Photographic Incidents of the War series, with applied paper printed label on verso reading Group, Officers On Board The Monitor, July 9, 1... > Item Details
Diamond Necklace Descended Directly in the Lincoln Family
Lot # 308 - Diamond Necklace Descended Directly in the Lincoln Family
Mid-19th century diamond necklace, 14K yellow gold with 34 old mine cut diamonds, each set in gold collet buttercup setting, the diamonds graduating in size from .20 carat to .45 carat, approximate total weight of all diamonds, 10 carats, clarity grade SI1-S12, color grade H-J. Length of necklace, 1... > Item Details
Robert Morris, Signer of the Declaration of Independence, ANS
Lot # 217 - Robert Morris, Signer of the Declaration of Independence, ANS
Clipped, 2 x 4.5 in. (sight). Pay to Mr. Stacey Hepburn on order Robt. Morris. Framed with lithograph of Morris to 9.25 x 12.75 in. Robert Morris (1734 - 1806) played a major role in financing the American Revolution and later managed the economy of the new nation. He also served the state of Pennsy... > Item Details
Lane Photographs of Fort Buford, North Dakota
Lot # 491 - Lane Photographs of Fort Buford, North Dakota
Lot of 2 ca 1890s gelatin silver images, 7.25 x 8.75 in., on brown 8 x 10 in. mounts with gold beveled edges and Lane's Fargo, N.D. imprint, one showing soldiers being drilled near the fort, one showing about 100 soldiers marching in a thin column across the plains. > Item Details
Colonel Marshall Lefferts, 7th New York Infantry, Watercolor Portrait
Lot # 105 - Colonel Marshall Lefferts, 7th New York Infantry, Watercolor Portrait
Ca late 19th century portrait, most likely a salt print enhanced with watercolors, depicting Colonel Marshall Lefferts dressed in uniform, with a kepi and sword in each hand, signed on verso D. Lefferts, undoubtedly a relative; 16 x 19.75 in., mounted, 20 x 24 in. Prior to the Civil War, Marshall Le... > Item Details
Zimmerman and Whitney Stereoviews of Chippewa Chiefs
Lot # 454 - Zimmerman and Whitney Stereoviews of Chippewa Chiefs
Lot of 2 stereoviews, including Wah Bo Jeeg [White Fisher] Chief Gull Lake Band Chippewas. An old warrior once taken prisoner by the Sioux and speaks the language, as printed below image, with Charles A. Zimmerman's St. Paul, Minnesota imprint; and a portrait of a Chippewa Chief, with Whitney's St. ... > Item Details
Alexander Gardner Stereoviews of Refugee Slaves
Lot # 65 - Alexander Gardner Stereoviews of Refugee Slaves
Lot of 2, both on yellow square-cornered mounts, including one with an applied paper printed label on verso from Gardner's Photographic Incidents of the War series, titled No. 519/Fugitive Negroes Crossing Rappahannock During Pope's Retreat, with an abridged version of the title on an inked manuscri... > Item Details
World War I-Era Photograph of Plains Indian in Uniform at Warrior Ceremony
Lot # 430 - World War I-Era Photograph of Plains Indian in Uniform at Warrior Ceremony
Large format silver print, 7.5 x 9.5 in. on 11.5 x 13.5 in. grey mount, no photographer identified; penciled date 1917 on mount just lower left of image. Soldier in WWI uniform holding a flag (with two large stars, similar to "son in service," but color not evident). There is a banner above that has... > Item Details
<i>An Examination of the New System of Society</i>
Lot # 340 - An Examination of the New System of Society
Fisher, W.L. An Examination of the New System of Society, by Robert Owen. Showing its Insufficiency to Reform Mankind, with Observations on the Operation of the Principle of Virtue in the Mind of Man. Philadelphia: John Mortimer, 1826. 8vo, plain boards with printed label, 85pp. Robert Owen (1771-18... > Item Details
U.S. Civil War Triplett & Scott Carbine Surcharged to a Kentucky Unit
Lot # 133 - U.S. Civil War Triplett & Scott Carbine Surcharged to a Kentucky Unit
.50 caliber, 30" barrel; S/N 3844. The state of Kentucky had a contract for Triplet & Scott carbines during the Civil War. > Item Details
Edward Curtis Photogravures of American Indian Women
Lot # 532 - Edward Curtis Photogravures of American Indian Women
Lot of 4 Edward Curtis photogravures printed on Japan Vellum, dated 1926, including the following: A Blackfoot Woman; Watching for the Salmon - Quinault; A Piegan Woman; and A Cochitt Woman; each measures 5.5 x 7.5 in., matted and framed, 16 x 20 in. > Item Details
William Pennington Signed Photograph of a Navajo Weaver
Lot # 538 - William Pennington Signed Photograph of a Navajo Weaver
Toned silver print titled Navajo and signed Pennington in black ink, ca 1910, 4.25 x 6 in., matted and framed, 10.5 x 12.5 in. > Item Details
A Collection of  2nd New Jersey Infantry CDVs
Lot # 16 - A Collection of 2nd New Jersey Infantry CDVs
Comprising 15 ink signed officers with 4 more unidentified captains/lieutenants plus one anonymous female, all once part of an album. The identified 2nd New Jersey men are: Lt. Colonel Charles Wiebecke (KIA 5/14/64 at Spotsylvania); Major James H. Close (Lt. Col. 39th N.J. 10/64, m/o 6/17/65); Assi... > Item Details
[AMERICAN INDIANS] <i>A Prayer Book</i>
Lot # 457 - [AMERICAN INDIANS] A Prayer Book
Davis, Rev. Solomon. Indian Prayer Book, or A Prayer Book in the Language of the Six Nations of Indians. New York: Swords, Stanford, & Co., 1837. 12mo, brown pressed cloth with gilt-lettered cover, 168pp. Previous owner's nameplate on front pastedown. > Item Details
H.B. Calfee & C.O. Allison Cabinet Photographs of the Northern Pacific Railroad
Lot # 500 - H.B. Calfee & C.O. Allison Cabinet Photographs of the Northern Pacific Railroad
Lot of 4, ca 1880s. Includes three images with Calfee's Yellowstone Park backmark depicting NPRR locomotives and the train station at Arlee, MT, and an image by Allison with his Carlton, MT imprint showing a small town and NPRR trestle crossing the Bitterroot River. A group of scarce Montana Terri... > Item Details
Scarce Photograph of Western Surveyor, Francis Vinton Greene
Lot # 375 - Scarce Photograph of Western Surveyor, Francis Vinton Greene
Lot of 2, one cdv and one cabinet card. Both taken at the same time, with imprint of Charles A. Zimmerman, St. Paul, MN. In the cabinet photo Greene is wearing cold-weather gear, a knit hat and scarf, and Cree fringed leather jacket, pants and embroidered fur mittens. The footwear is also Cree in de... > Item Details
Frank Rande, Notorious Outlaw, CDV Portrait
Lot # 497 - Frank Rande, Notorious Outlaw, CDV Portrait
Showing the outlaw with a Smith & Wesson American pistol in hand, another tucked into his belt, and a quizzical look on his face, imprinted on verso: Copyrighted by Chas. C. Scott, '77. / Frank Rande, / "The American Brigand" / "The Knox County Desperado." / "The Bri... > Item Details
1851 Colt Navy with Papers SRS Michigan 10th Volunteer Cavalry
Lot # 106 - 1851 Colt Navy with Papers SRS Michigan 10th Volunteer Cavalry
.36 caliber, 7.5" octagonal barrel with New York Address, S/N 142060, brass backstrap and triggerguard. All numbers match, One piece walnut grips. With letter from Springfield Research Service certifying this revolver by serial number was issued to Co. C., 10th Michigan Volunteer Cavalry, Pvt. Sytz... > Item Details
ITEMS 1-20 of 20
SKIP TO PAGE: