Lot 306    

Seneca Chief Governor Blacksnake Quarter Plate Daguerreotype
2009, Winter American History, Dec 9
Identified with a slip of inked paper beneath the cover glass, and with the following identification pasted onto the pad of the case: Governor Blacksnake (Tha-o-hawyuth) or (Tha-o-wa-nyuth) The Nephew (Seneca). Died at Cold Spring, NY in South Valley Allegany [sic] Reservation Dec 26th 1859 age 117 or 120 years. A large and powerful man. Photo artist F.C. Flint 402 So. Salina St. Syracuse, N.Y. In spite of this detailed information, we could find no listing for Flint.

Born near Seneca Lake about 1753, this important Seneca war-chief was known to his people as Chainbreaker; to Whites he was Governor Blacksnake. According to some of his early biographers he was given this moniker by George Washington, though this may be merely apocryphal.

Chainbreaker/Blacksnake was the nephew of Cornplanter, an important Seneca war-chief and Handsome Lake, a Seneca religious figure. Cornplanter and Handsome Lake were both members of the Wolf clan, and in the matrilineal Seneca society, these two elders were responsible for the upbringing of their sister’s male child – Chainbreaker. By the time of the Revolutionary War, Chainbreaker/Blacksnake was a young warrior. While not yet old enough to be a diplomatic leader, he was present with Cornplanter at the peace negotiations after the war. This close association resulted in another common moniker, “The Nephew.”

By the second quarter of the 19th century, having won their “Second Revolution” in the War of 1812, Americans were constructing their “national myth” (Abler 2005: 10) and Indian Wars and the Revolution, as well as the frontier in general, were a major part of this. Chainbreaker/Blacksnake became something of a local celebrity in upstate New York, so in the 1840s he began relating his memories to young Ben Williams – the Revolution from the viewpoint of a native veteran. Williams clearly had an eye toward publishing the Seneca chief’s biography, though never finished the task. The great collector and historian Lyman Draper purchased Williams manuscript for $25, which serves as the basis for much of what we know about Chainbreaker’s/Blacksnake’s life. (This was Draper’s first purchase of what would eventually fill 484 volumes, now housed at the State Historical Society of Wisconsin.)

Chainbreaker’s/Blacksnake’s memoirs contain information about the French and Indian Wars -- second-hand knowledge gleaned at many council fires as a young boy; the American Revolution -- first-hand knowledge from a warrior; Indian conflicts at the end of the 18th century, again as a participant (many villages were burned in the late 1790s); and the War of 1812. The next period seems to be “missing.” Williams’ notes do not cover much of the intervening decades, whether lost in the fire, or not written down, or not deemed important, is unknown.

Chainbreaker/Blacksnake was also at the center of one of the great transformational events in Seneca history: the formation of the Code of Handsome Lake. While there are numerous variations on the story, the general scenario is consistent: Handsome Lake fell into a coma – perhaps induced by alcohol abuse. Seeking help, his daughter ran to Blacksnake and Cornplanter for aid. With the aid of Blacksnake, Handsome Lake was revived, and reported that during his sleep had had a vision. Three spirit messengers warned about dangers of alcohol consumption and witchcraft. Subsequent visions added other “evil practices” such as sexual promiscuity, wife beating, fighting and gambling. From this point forward, Handsome Lake preached against the abuse of alcohol, and urged the Iroquois to adopt his new “code” that incorporated elements of Christianity and traditional Iroquois culture. The new religion gained in popularity, with none more fervent follower than Chainbreaker, himself, having witnessed first hand Handsome Lake’s near death and recovery. Some sources indicate that it was Chainbreaker who dictated the Code of Handsome Lake to be written down years after the prophet’s death (in the late 1840s). The new religion had enough Christian elements to meet with Quaker approval, as well as that of Thomas Jefferson. The Quakers had established schools and other social services on the Iroquois reservations, and their writings refer to Chainbreaker as Handsome Lake’s “privy Counsellor” (Abler 2005: 218).

The present daguerreotype of Blacksnake has been reproduced in several volumes on the Seneca. It appears first in Donaldson’s 1892 volume on the Seneca, facing p.28, with no attribution. A copy of the daguerreoptype was also used as the cover illustration of Adler’s (2002) biography, and it was used again by Abler (2005) as the frontispiece. None of these publication provide any credit or attribution as to the original owner. The daguerreotype - along with a box of other unrelated images -- was recently found in a warehouse in upstate New York.

An exceptionally important image of a well-known Native American diplomat and historical figure. During his lifetime Governor Blacksnake saw the conquest of North America by the British; the birth of the United States of America; and the decline of his people from members of a powerful Confederacy to a handful of poor villagers scattered on a reservation on a fraction of their original territory.

See the following for publications using this same image: Abler, Thomas S. (ed.) (2005) Chainbreaker: The Revolutionary War memoirs of Governor Blacksnake as told to Benjamin Williams. University of Nebraska Press. Adler, Jeanne W. (ed.) (2002) Chainbreaker’s War: A Seneca Chief Remembers the American Revolution. Hensonville (NY): Black Dome Press. Donaldson, Thomas (1892) … Indians. The Six Nations of New York: Cayugas, Mohawks (St. Regis), Oneidas, Onondagas, Senecas, Tuscarowas. Extra Census Bulletin. Washington. U.S. Government Printing Office.
Sold: $22,325.00
Price includes
Buyer's Premium
      Ask a Question

All Images

don't miss

an opportunity to bid. You can't win if you're not in.

sign up to bid

what's it worth?

ask the experts

sell your item

start selling
Nevada Senator William M. Stewart Presentation Silver, Plus
Lot # 36 - Nevada Senator William M. Stewart Presentation Silver, Plus
an archive of Senator William M. Stewart items, including a leather wallet with a 1905 inscription, a Mexican woven coin bag and its letter of documentation, photographs of the senator and a CDV of Jefferson Davis, a miniature on ivory of the senator, with leather case, a personal letter to Mrs. W. ... > Item Details
A.F. Randall Boudoir Photograph of <i>White Mountain Apaches</i>
Lot # 301 - A.F. Randall Boudoir Photograph of White Mountain Apaches
Albumen studio portrait of two seated women and an Apache man holding a Frank Wesson .32 Caliber Rim-fire Two Trigger Rifle; manuscript title below image on recto; verso with Randall's Wilcox, A.T. backmark. > Item Details
War Department Orders for the Isaac Stevens Expedition
Lot # 121 - War Department Orders for the Isaac Stevens Expedition
2pp typeset on folded blue paper with eagle blindstamp in upper left, orders issued by Jefferson Davis as Secretary of War, 8 Apr. 1853. Bvt. Capt. George B. McClellan was under orders to report to Isaac Stevens, Governor of Washington Territory. Along with members of Lieut. Donelson's engineer comp... > Item Details
Large Group of 4th Cavalry Missouri State Militia CDVs
Lot # 154 - Large Group of 4th Cavalry Missouri State Militia CDVs
Comprising 18 officers and 3 enlisted men, with 5 sundry civilians. Included are both of the regiments’ officer-casualties — Captain Blair and Lieutenant Dale — killed at Big Blue, Missouri in October 1864. Two other military views depict the regimental Adjutant Charles W. Bowman. The cartes sign... > Item Details
Photograph of a Ute Indian, probably by William Henry Jackson
Lot # 262 - Photograph of a Ute Indian, probably by William Henry Jackson
4.25 x 7.5 in. image on 8 x 10 in. mount, marked in the negative, #A.1742 San Frisco Weva copyright 1898 by Jackson-Smith Photo Co. Denver, Colo. The Jackson-Smith Photo Co. operated in Denver 1898-1899. Portraits of this man were also copyrighted by Smith-Hassell Co. in 1898 & 1899. Given the s... > Item Details
A Fine CDV of Captain Raphael Semmes, CSN,
Lot # 152 - A Fine CDV of Captain Raphael Semmes, CSN,
a published view of Semmes leaning on studio podium with draped first pattern Confederate National Flag. This is an early photograph of the flamboyant Semmes with imprint of “A Duperly & Sons, Kingston, Jamaica” probably taken on January 21, 1863 when the raider Alabama shipped at Port Royal, Kings... > Item Details
Four CDV-Sized Tintypes of Armed Westerners
Lot # 367 - Four CDV-Sized Tintypes of Armed Westerners
Lot of four tintype studio portraits of Western characters, ca 1875-1885, 2.5 x 3.5 in., including the following: a man with a small revolver and hunting knife in his belt; a man with an unknown revolver on his right hip; two men posed, one at left with an ivory-gripped Remington Cartridge Revolver ... > Item Details
Civil War Letters of John Barnes, PA 71st Infantry, KIA
Lot # 175 - Civil War Letters of John Barnes, PA 71st Infantry, KIA
1861-1862. 71st Pennsylvania Infantry, Co. B (California Regiment); 21 letters, envelopes (some patriotics), 1 document. The California Regiment was one of the most unusual and illustrious units in the Union army during the Civil War. Organized on May 21, 1861, by Edwin D. Baker, the U.S. Senator f... > Item Details
Political CDV Album with P.T. Barnum CDV and Letter
Lot # 70 - Political CDV Album with P.T. Barnum CDV and Letter
Typical cdv album, approx. 6 x 8.5 in., two clasps, each page with space for 2 cdvs. Album contains more than 80 cdv's, 72 of which are identified members of the General Assembly, plus Governors English (2), Buckingham, Ingersoll, and one of U.S. Grant. There are also 8 tintypes, which, along with t... > Item Details
Half Plate Tintype of Unidentified Union Officer in Union Case
Lot # 133 - Half Plate Tintype of Unidentified Union Officer in Union Case
A studio portrait of an unknown 2nd lieutenant with drawn Foot Officer’s sword and belted Colt Root revolver. He wears the regulation frock coat with red tinted sash and kepi bearing an illegible two digit number within the infantry bugle. > Item Details
F.A. Rinehart Rare Catalog of Photographs
Lot # 285 - F.A. Rinehart Rare Catalog of Photographs
Small 24mo in printed card stock covers, staple and glued binding, entitled Rinehart's Platinum Prints of American Indians, n.p., 1899, Omaha, Neb.. With 63pp, nearly half with three photomechanical images per page of Native Americans, printed by the Press of Mize and Stearns, Chicago. > Item Details
CDV of Lt. Col. Julius P. Garesche with ADS
Lot # 184 - CDV of Lt. Col. Julius P. Garesche with ADS
No back mark. The common view of Garesche wearing religious medal. Julius Peter Garesche was an 1841 West Point graduate decapitated by a stray shell at Stones’ River on December 31, 1862 while riding with General Rosecrans rallying the line of battle. Described as aloof, Garesche was a devout Ca... > Item Details
Escaped Slave <i>Gordon</i>, Rare CDV Portrait
Lot # 38 - Escaped Slave Gordon, Rare CDV Portrait
One of the most famous, or infamous, images of American slavery shows the back and profile of a young African American male slave who was bull-whipped after being captured while trying to escape, which left his back horribly scarred. Known only as Gordon, he made it across Union lines ca 1863, and N... > Item Details
Joshua B. Teadwell, 45th and 54th Massachusetts Archive
Lot # 168 - Joshua B. Teadwell, 45th and 54th Massachusetts Archive
Surgeon Joshua Brackett Treadwell Letters, 1863-1865. 45th, 5th (100 days), and 54th Massachusetts Infantry; 31 items. Shortly after graduating from Harvard Medical School in 1862, Joshua Brackett Treadwell volunteered for duty in the Civil War as an assistant surgeon. Over the next three years, h... > Item Details
Early Store Ledger Books Featuring Simon Kenton
Lot # 44 - Early Store Ledger Books Featuring Simon Kenton
Lot of 5 account and ledger books. Samuel J. Waters Account Book, 1796-1797 and 1841-1855; ca 260pp in two sections. Although the owner has not been identified, the present account book provides a valuable record of economic activity in early Kentucky. The book is divided into two clear sections, ... > Item Details
Photographs of 19th and 20th Century Outlaws From the Pinkerton Agency
Lot # 385 - Photographs of 19th and 20th Century Outlaws From the Pinkerton Agency
Lot of 31 photographs in various sizes, including the following cdv-sized portraits on print-out paper and albumen, collotype, silver, photogravure, or halftone print portraits, some with handwritten identification and information on verso: William Coleman (alias Billy Coleman), ca 1870s-1880s (4); ... > Item Details
Navajo Indians, Scarce Cartes de Visite
Lot # 270 - Navajo Indians, Scarce Cartes de Visite
Lot of 2 anonymous albumen portraits, both marked in ink on the back, Comanche Indian, one with additional note, Guaymas Mexico Christmas 1871. These rare, early portraits likely date to the 1860s. We also think they are Navajo, not Comanche, in spite of the label. > Item Details
Buffalo Bill Cody Signed Inscription Plus <i>Wild West</i> Program
Lot # 388 - Buffalo Bill Cody Signed Inscription Plus Wild West Program
Lot of 2. Card 3 x 4.5 in. with Very Truly Yours W.F. Cody, Buffalo Bill, Feb. 22nd, 1882. Program from Greater New York, 1897. 8vo, chromolithographed paper wraps, 64 numbered pages plus 16pp ads (8 front, 8 rear), plus 4pp of ads inserted between pp 2-3. > Item Details
Mexican War Manuscript Map of the Siege of Vera Cruz
Lot # 113 - Mexican War Manuscript Map of the Siege of Vera Cruz
9 x 14 in., on cardboard (originally). Verso with Hoyt. Label A map of the country lying Southerly from Vera Cruz and occupied by the American forces during the siege. Drawn from memory. There is the general "lay of the land," with a marsh, meadows, mills noted. A road and railroad are sketched in. ... > Item Details
Jicarilla Apache Warrior Photograph by D.B. Chase
Lot # 298 - Jicarilla Apache Warrior Photograph by D.B. Chase
an albumen studio portrait on boudoir card 5 x 8 in., identified in the negative as No. 79. Apache Warrior from Jicarilla Agency, by Dana B. Chase, ca. 1887. Printed notes about Santa Fe, New Mexico and railway advertisements on the back. > Item Details
ITEMS 1-20 of 20