Lot 69    

1877 Election Tickets,
2010, American History Absentee and Live Auction, January 21
3 x 4.5 in., one for Feb. 13, the other for Feb. 15, 1877. Counting the Vote for President and Vice-President, Admit Bearer to Gallery of House of Representatives.

The 1876 election was the most disputed election in history until 2000. It actually began with the conventions. It was thought that Blaine would win the Republican nomination, and he seemed to get closer with every ballot, but no majority emerged. Leaders of the reform faction got together to consider other candidates, settling on Ohio governor, Rutherford B. Hayes. Hayes was nominated on the seventh ballot - the first on which he was put forth. Tilden had an easier time in the Democratic convention, but the Tammany Hall faction strongly opposed Tilden and wielded some influence, though not enough to block Tilden's nomination.

The election itself was also fraught with problems. There was widespread "terrorism" on the part of radical whites in the South, discouraging black participation in the election. Other "improprieties" included printing Republican symbols on Democratic tickets (for the benefit of illiterate voters), confusing the issue. Colorado was admitted to the union on August 1st, too late to print ballots, organize polling, etc. Oregon disputed the selection of one of its electors, since the man, although retired by the time of the election, had been postmaster earlier in the year - a Federal position making him ineligible in the opinion of the Democratic governor, who then selected a Democratic elector to replace the Republican one. And again, the Florida votes were disputed.

On the first count in the electoral college, Tilden had 184 electoral votes, Hayes 165, and 20 votes were disputed. Many of the disputes had to do with certification of the electoral votes - some had the state attorney's signature, others the governor's, one state had a candidate's signature, and Oregon submitted two sets (one with 3 votes for Hayes, the other with one for Tilden and 2 for Hayes - one signed by the secretary of state, one by the governor).

Since the electoral votes are counted in the full Congress by the President of the Senate, as system which had worked up to this point, Democrats feared that the Republican Vice President could chose which set of disputed votes to recognize in the count and sway the election. So a law was passed forming a committee to settle the result. It was composed of five members from each house of Congress and five members of the Supreme Court. The selection of these members was also disputed, though not as vigorously. It has long been alleged that there were some "back room" deals being made, most centering on electing Hayes in exchange for ending Reconstruction and getting the "carpetbaggers" out of the South - something for which southern Democrats had been petitioning for a long time. These deals, if indeed they were made, may have smoothed over the selection of the committee members.

Ultimately all 20 disputed votes were awarded to Hayes, giving him the election by just one electoral vote, 185-184. And Tilden became the first candidate, but not the last, to loose an election while winning the popular vote. Surely those who were present at the vote-counting in Congress that February of 1877 thought that anything might happen (even though it was supposed to have been worked out in the special committee). The actual certification of the election in Congress seems to have been anticlimactic.


Condition:  
Excellent.
Sold: $264.38
Price includes
Buyer's Premium
      Ask a Question

All Images

don't miss

an opportunity to bid. You can't win if you're not in.

sign up to bid

what's it worth?

ask the experts

sell your item

start selling
CDV Album
Lot # 47 - CDV Album
In latching leather case with gilt page edges. Includes 33 various cdvs of men, women, and children. > Item Details
Betsy Ross' Father, Samuel Griscom DS
Lot # 100 - Betsy Ross' Father, Samuel Griscom DS
8.25 x 13 in. partially printed contract, 24 May 1762. Signed by Samuel Griscom, "House Carpenter am held and firmly bound unto James Stephens of [Philadelphia] Baker, the surviving executor ... of Isaac Stephens ... in the sum of two hundred and fifty pounds." Half plus interest to be repaid in on... > Item Details
Scarce Oregon G.A.R. Publication,
Lot # 209 - Scarce Oregon G.A.R. Publication,
A rare 1899 booklet documenting the military history of Yamhill County Oregon, written by J.C. Cooper. Contains numerous biographies and images of Northwest pioneers. Only two copies known to exist. > Item Details
<i>Marx</i> Chromolithograph Tin  of </i>Jumpin' Jeep, B.O. Plenty</i>, Drummers, Plus
Lot # 148 - Marx Chromolithograph Tin of Jumpin' Jeep, B.O. Plenty, Drummers, Plus
Lot of five, ca 1940-1950. Includes a tin wind-up with four GIs riding in a 22 C Jumping Jeep. Lithographed views of the GI figures, steering wheel, and Jeep accessories, are included, in original finish, 5.5 x 3.25 x 4.25 in. high. Plus a marked Marx uniformed chromolithographed tin wind-up drummer... > Item Details
Mt. Vernon Relic with Washington Portrait
Lot # 54 - Mt. Vernon Relic with Washington Portrait
Ca 1859. A Mount Vernon relic, home of George Washington. Wood medallion featuring fine engraving on obverse by American Bank Note Company featuring Washington portrait with Columbia, and Mt. Vernon in background. Reverse label dated November 14, 1859 details that wood frame is made of wood grown on... > Item Details
Pro-Union Songsheets and Souvenir Book,
Lot # 197 - Pro-Union Songsheets and Souvenir Book,
lot of 3. Includes manuscript music and lyrics for The Prisoner's Hope, with 1866 date, decorated with print cutouts of McClellan, the Union flag and eagle. Approx. 7.5 x 12.5 in., although the edges are scuffed and missing some paper. The musical score and chorus are on the front, verses on back. T... > Item Details
Quarter Plate Ambrotype of Early Church
Late 19th-Century San Francisco Publications,
Lot # 333 - Late 19th-Century San Francisco Publications,
lot of 4 includes an 1896 booklet The Livermore Sanitarium, Established by Dr. John W. Robertson, located in Livermore, California. One known copy. PLUS an 1885 booklet Why Modern Cremation Should Replace Earth-Burial An Expose of the Dangers Caused by Inhumation, published by the San Francisco Crem... > Item Details
Cincinnati Architect Alfred O. Elzner Office Archive of Photographs, Drawings, and Other Materials
Lot # 114 - Cincinnati Architect Alfred O. Elzner Office Archive of Photographs, Drawings, and Other Materials
Lot of 80+ photographs, sketches, drawings, and documents related to noted Cincinnati architect, Alfred O. Elzner (1862-1933). The grouping features 50+ photographs capturing exterior and interior views of homes, many local to Cincinnati such as the Ault Residence, as well as high-rise office buildi... > Item Details
New York City Subway Ground Breaking <i>Tunnel Day</i> Photograph
Lot # 52 - New York City Subway Ground Breaking Tunnel Day Photograph
Back of mount pencil inscribed Taken by / George…City Hall / Decorated on Sat – / March 24th 1900 / Tunnel Day. Quite an historic moment for the Big Apple! 6.5 x 5.5 in. overall with mount. The tunnel that would become the subway system started at City Hall on March 24, 1900. Mayor van Wyck broke gr... > Item Details
Ninth Plate Ruby Ambrotype of Triple-Armed Trooper
Lot # 155 - Ninth Plate Ruby Ambrotype of Triple-Armed Trooper
An unidentified character sporting an 1860s pompadour, armed to the teeth with M1840 "wristbreaker," belted revolver, and sheathed knife. He wears a striped civilian shirt showing the texture of the cotton cloth with a rectangular eagle belt plate. Under magnification the spread-wing eagles are vi... > Item Details
William Henry Jackson, <i>U.S. Signal Station on Pike's Peak</i> Photograph
Lot # 277 - William Henry Jackson, U.S. Signal Station on Pike's Peak Photograph
Circa 1870s large format albumen photograph on large sheet board by William Henry Jackson (1843-1942), most likely taken on 1870 U.S. government survey led by Ferdinand Hayden. Picture shows U.S. signal station on Pike's Peak in Colorado. Photograph labeled 1220 - U.S. Signal Station on Pike's Peak ... > Item Details
L.A. Huffman Collotype, <i>The Honyocker</i>
Lot # 293 - L.A. Huffman Collotype, The Honyocker
Later hand-tinted print from Huffman's original glass plate negative. In weathered wood frame. "Honyocker" was the derogatory term given to farmers/squatters by the ranchers who had been on the Plains for decades. They "turned the prairie upside down" with their plows and fenced off their farms with... > Item Details
CDV of Colonel Regis DeTrobriand
Lot # 164 - CDV of Colonel Regis DeTrobriand
An unsigned full view with sword by Anthony after Brady having early red border and graphic Anthony imprint. Expatriate son of a minor French Baron, Regis De Trobriand (1816-1897) was the archetypical 19th century Renaissance man equally at home with literature and war. De Trobriand became colonel ... > Item Details
Real Estate Broadsides, 19th Century
Lot # 128 - Real Estate Broadsides, 19th Century
Lot of 4 real estate broadsides including one 23.75 x 38 in. with bold heading Administrator's Sale of Valuable Real Estate. Advertising sale of estate of Henry Smith of Middletown, Dauphin Co., PA for the date of January 25th, 1883. With illustrated image of house and large block print lettering th... > Item Details
<i>Atlas of Logan County Ohio</i>, 1890
Lot # 139 - Atlas of Logan County Ohio, 1890
14.75 x 17.5 in. bound book with gold print on cover reading Atlas of Logan County Ohio, D.J.Lake & Co., 1890. Inside cover contains road map of Logan Co. Ohio. Atlas includes table of contents, with colored maps of townships, towns, and villages within Logan Co. > Item Details
San Francisco <i>Report on the Causes of Municipal Corruption</i>
Lot # 335 - San Francisco Report on the Causes of Municipal Corruption
1910 booklet Report on the Causes of Municipal Corruption in San Francisco, as disclosed by the Investigation of the Oliver Grand Jury, and the Prosecution of Certain Persons, for Bribery and Other Offenses Against the State. Interesting report presented to Edward R. Taylor, San Francisco mayor, chr... > Item Details
Large Lot of Turn of the Century Cabinet Card Photographs of Men, Women, and Children
Lot # 42 - Large Lot of Turn of the Century Cabinet Card Photographs of Men, Women, and Children
Over 200 various cabinet card photographs of men, women, and children from the turn of the century. > Item Details
Bret  Harte, <i>The Heathen Chinee</i> Poem
Lot # 124 - Bret Harte, The Heathen Chinee Poem
Written as a parody of Swinburne's "Atalanta" and published under the above title in The Overland, this poem was soon being reprinted and republished across the country as "The Heathen Chinee." Although Harte was being critical of the Irish workers' attitudes toward Chinese laborers in California, t... > Item Details
Well Fargo & Company Express Rail Passes,
Lot # 327 - Well Fargo & Company Express Rail Passes,
lot of 2, both 2.5 x 4 in. First from 1902 for F.E. Greene, Secy. to Gen Man, C & NW Ry. Second from 1913 for E.E. Smyth, Traffic Manager Missouri & North Arkansas RR. Countersigned by W.B. Clark, who is listed as Assistant Secretary in 1915 (Gardiner, the other potential signee, was Secretary). > Item Details
ITEMS 1-20 of 20
SKIP TO PAGE: