Lot 69    

1877 Election Tickets,
2010, American History Absentee and Live Auction, January 21
3 x 4.5 in., one for Feb. 13, the other for Feb. 15, 1877. Counting the Vote for President and Vice-President, Admit Bearer to Gallery of House of Representatives.

The 1876 election was the most disputed election in history until 2000. It actually began with the conventions. It was thought that Blaine would win the Republican nomination, and he seemed to get closer with every ballot, but no majority emerged. Leaders of the reform faction got together to consider other candidates, settling on Ohio governor, Rutherford B. Hayes. Hayes was nominated on the seventh ballot - the first on which he was put forth. Tilden had an easier time in the Democratic convention, but the Tammany Hall faction strongly opposed Tilden and wielded some influence, though not enough to block Tilden's nomination.

The election itself was also fraught with problems. There was widespread "terrorism" on the part of radical whites in the South, discouraging black participation in the election. Other "improprieties" included printing Republican symbols on Democratic tickets (for the benefit of illiterate voters), confusing the issue. Colorado was admitted to the union on August 1st, too late to print ballots, organize polling, etc. Oregon disputed the selection of one of its electors, since the man, although retired by the time of the election, had been postmaster earlier in the year - a Federal position making him ineligible in the opinion of the Democratic governor, who then selected a Democratic elector to replace the Republican one. And again, the Florida votes were disputed.

On the first count in the electoral college, Tilden had 184 electoral votes, Hayes 165, and 20 votes were disputed. Many of the disputes had to do with certification of the electoral votes - some had the state attorney's signature, others the governor's, one state had a candidate's signature, and Oregon submitted two sets (one with 3 votes for Hayes, the other with one for Tilden and 2 for Hayes - one signed by the secretary of state, one by the governor).

Since the electoral votes are counted in the full Congress by the President of the Senate, as system which had worked up to this point, Democrats feared that the Republican Vice President could chose which set of disputed votes to recognize in the count and sway the election. So a law was passed forming a committee to settle the result. It was composed of five members from each house of Congress and five members of the Supreme Court. The selection of these members was also disputed, though not as vigorously. It has long been alleged that there were some "back room" deals being made, most centering on electing Hayes in exchange for ending Reconstruction and getting the "carpetbaggers" out of the South - something for which southern Democrats had been petitioning for a long time. These deals, if indeed they were made, may have smoothed over the selection of the committee members.

Ultimately all 20 disputed votes were awarded to Hayes, giving him the election by just one electoral vote, 185-184. And Tilden became the first candidate, but not the last, to loose an election while winning the popular vote. Surely those who were present at the vote-counting in Congress that February of 1877 thought that anything might happen (even though it was supposed to have been worked out in the special committee). The actual certification of the election in Congress seems to have been anticlimactic.

Sold: $264.38
Price includes
Buyer's Premium
      Ask a Question

All Images

don't miss

an opportunity to bid. You can't win if you're not in.

sign up to bid

what's it worth?

ask the experts

sell your item

start selling
Ninth Plate Ruby Ambrotype of Union Soldier
Lot # 154 - Ninth Plate Ruby Ambrotype of Union Soldier
Standing soldier in uniform with hands clasped, housed in a geometric Union case. > Item Details
Map of the State of Kentucky by Russell, ca 1794
Lot # 135 - Map of the State of Kentucky by Russell, ca 1794
16 x 19.5 in.; not colored; London: H.D. Symonds. Including most of Tennessee, although it was still the "Southwestern Territory" on this map. North of the Ohio River is part of the Northwest Territory, with Fort Washington marked, but no mention of Cincinnati. Just south of Tennessee and Davidson C... > Item Details
National and Texas State Grange Constitution
Lot # 347 - National and Texas State Grange Constitution
1885 booklet Constitution and Declaration of Purposes of the National Grange, P. of H., Together with the Constitution of the Texas State Grange. Includes rules for trials in subordinate granges, parliamentary guide, and grange stores and dividends. Front and back covers display excellent advertisin... > Item Details
Pittsburgh, PA Photographs of Properties, 1927-1930
Lot # 53 - Pittsburgh, PA Photographs of Properties, 1927-1930
Lot of 94; all 8 x 11 in. with labels in the negative: Pgh. Pass. Sta. IMPTS, the direction of view, location, negative number, and date. Plus two sections cut from the Pittsburgh Sun-Telegraph of March 21, 1935 of the burned-out Old St. Patrick's church (below). In ring binder with letter on front ... > Item Details
[AMERICAN INDIANS] Catlin, George,
Lot # 274 - [AMERICAN INDIANS] Catlin, George,
Illustrations of the Manners, Customs, and Condition of the North American Indians: in a Series of Letters and Notes Written During Eight years of Travel and Adventure Among the Wildest and Most Remarkable Tribes Now Existing. With Three Hundred and Sixty Engravings from the Author's Original Painti... > Item Details
Twelve 19th Century <i>Virginia Military Institute</i> Brass Buttons,
Lot # 202 - Twelve 19th Century Virginia Military Institute Brass Buttons,
possibly pre-war, domed brass with state seal and Cadet/VMI with D. Evans, Attleboro backmark, 0.82" diameter. > Item Details
Carl Moon Photograph of a Plains Indian
Lot # 269 - Carl Moon Photograph of a Plains Indian
10.5 x 13.25 in. silver gelatin profile view in a 13 x 16 in. wooden frame. > Item Details
Sixth Plate Postmortem Ambrotype of a Gentleman
Lot # 20 - Sixth Plate Postmortem Ambrotype of a Gentleman
Anonymous; head and shoulders. In full composition case, hinge splitting. > Item Details
Seminole Indian Kodak No. 2 1895 Photographs
Lot # 271 - Seminole Indian Kodak No. 2 1895 Photographs
Lot of 5 silver gelatin photographs includes photo of a snared crocodile, marked Crocodiles head Spring 1895 in ink on verso. PLUS a photo of Seminole men, women, and children standing in a line in front of huts, marked Seminoles 1895 in pencil on verso. PLUS a photo of two men standing on a canoe w... > Item Details
Sixth Plate Tintype of a Postmortem Woman
Lot # 35 - Sixth Plate Tintype of a Postmortem Woman
Woman facing camera with clasped hands and closed eyes, with subtle hand-tinted cheeks. > Item Details
Handwritten Sale of Steamboat <i>Phoenix</i>
Lot # 110 - Handwritten Sale of Steamboat Phoenix
1855. In part: If you will have put on Board the Steem [sic] Boat Pheonix [sic] all that was taken off the said boat before the day of the proposed Public Sale, I will take the said Steem Boat and $9500.00 for my Steem Mill Property. But in the event of your accepting my offer here I want it... to b... > Item Details
<i>Uncle Tom's Cabin</i>, 1853,
Lot # 80 - Uncle Tom's Cabin, 1853,
Stowe, Harriet Beecher. Uncle Tom's Cabin: or, Life Among The Lowly. Boston: John P. Jewett And Company. Cleveland, Ohio: Jewett, Proctor & Worthington. 1853. Two Hundred And Thirty Third Thousand. > Item Details
Early Tombstone and Charleston, A.T. Certificates and Receipts
Lot # 346 - Early Tombstone and Charleston, A.T. Certificates and Receipts
lot of 4. Includes check drawn on the Pima County Bank, Tombstone, 28 Oct. 1880. Withdrawal for Owen Gilmartin. Plus cover letter for account at Springer & Hackes, Successors to Springer & Detoy, Dealers in GEneral Merchandise, Charleston, A.T. 4/13/1881. Acknowledging receipt of $50 toward account.... > Item Details
Early Nevada Mining Newspaper, <i>The Humboldt Register</i>
Lot # 312 - Early Nevada Mining Newspaper, The Humboldt Register
An 1865 Nevada newspaper The Humboldt Register, Volume II - Number 48, Unionville Nevada. A very early Nevada newspaper printed just a few months after Nevada lost its territorial status and gained statehood. This copy was published during the latter part of the civil war in Unionville, Humboldt Cou... > Item Details
<i>Confederate War Papers</i>, by Gustavus W. Smith,
Lot # 198 - Confederate War Papers, by Gustavus W. Smith,
Front cover and spine marked Confederate War Papers Gustavus W. Smith in gilt. Inside cover contains portrait and autograph of author. Back page contains fold out map titled Seven Pines or Fair Oaks - Position of Forces on Morning of June 1st. Copyrighted 1884. > Item Details
Philadelphia Surveys of Land, 1772-1773
Lot # 101 - Philadelphia Surveys of Land, 1772-1773
Lot of 2. First is 8 x 13.5 in., 23 July 1772. Survey of a strip of land 30 x 250 ft. between the properties of Joseph and James Bringhurst and land formerly belonging to Jonathan Dickinson "commonly called the Burnt Houses." Robert Dills for John Lukens, Surveyor General of Pennsylvania (including ... > Item Details
William H. Vanderbilt Signed Stock Certificate
Lot # 99 - William H. Vanderbilt Signed Stock Certificate
Pine Creek Railway Company certificate, $1000, issued 20 March 1885. Engraved by the American Bank Note Company with vignettes in corners. Signed by W. Vanderbilt and Chauncey Depew as trustees. Mortgage bond guaranteed by New York Central and Hudson River, Philadelphia and Reading and Corning Cowan... > Item Details
Survey of James Buchanan's Land, 1863
Lot # 88 - Survey of James Buchanan's Land, 1863
13.5 x 16 in. sheet folded. First three pages have measurements and calculations of areas of "Northern field," "Upper field," and "Southern part." Top of first page: Calculation of Land in Manheim Twp. Lanc'ter Co. belonging to Hon. James Buchanan occupied by Col. S.G. Stambaugh. Surveyed Nov. 10, 1... > Item Details
Black Civil War Soldier Discharge Signed Twice by General James Oakes,
Lot # 189 - Black Civil War Soldier Discharge Signed Twice by General James Oakes,
Oakes, James (1826-1910), brigadier-general. Partially printed MsS, 1p, 8.5" x 11.25". Springfield, Illinois. November 23, 1865. Addressed to black soldier David Bell. Discharge papers of black soldier David Bell, Kent Co., Delware. Bell, who fought under the 29th regiment of U.S. Colored Troops, wa... > Item Details
Half Plate Ambrotype of Couple at Niagara Falls
Lot # 15 - Half Plate Ambrotype of Couple at Niagara Falls
Image features husband standing and wife seated on bench with Niagara Falls in the background. Housed in an embossed leather case. > Item Details
ITEMS 1-20 of 20