Lot 69    

1877 Election Tickets,
2010, American History Absentee and Live Auction, January 21
3 x 4.5 in., one for Feb. 13, the other for Feb. 15, 1877. Counting the Vote for President and Vice-President, Admit Bearer to Gallery of House of Representatives.

The 1876 election was the most disputed election in history until 2000. It actually began with the conventions. It was thought that Blaine would win the Republican nomination, and he seemed to get closer with every ballot, but no majority emerged. Leaders of the reform faction got together to consider other candidates, settling on Ohio governor, Rutherford B. Hayes. Hayes was nominated on the seventh ballot - the first on which he was put forth. Tilden had an easier time in the Democratic convention, but the Tammany Hall faction strongly opposed Tilden and wielded some influence, though not enough to block Tilden's nomination.

The election itself was also fraught with problems. There was widespread "terrorism" on the part of radical whites in the South, discouraging black participation in the election. Other "improprieties" included printing Republican symbols on Democratic tickets (for the benefit of illiterate voters), confusing the issue. Colorado was admitted to the union on August 1st, too late to print ballots, organize polling, etc. Oregon disputed the selection of one of its electors, since the man, although retired by the time of the election, had been postmaster earlier in the year - a Federal position making him ineligible in the opinion of the Democratic governor, who then selected a Democratic elector to replace the Republican one. And again, the Florida votes were disputed.

On the first count in the electoral college, Tilden had 184 electoral votes, Hayes 165, and 20 votes were disputed. Many of the disputes had to do with certification of the electoral votes - some had the state attorney's signature, others the governor's, one state had a candidate's signature, and Oregon submitted two sets (one with 3 votes for Hayes, the other with one for Tilden and 2 for Hayes - one signed by the secretary of state, one by the governor).

Since the electoral votes are counted in the full Congress by the President of the Senate, as system which had worked up to this point, Democrats feared that the Republican Vice President could chose which set of disputed votes to recognize in the count and sway the election. So a law was passed forming a committee to settle the result. It was composed of five members from each house of Congress and five members of the Supreme Court. The selection of these members was also disputed, though not as vigorously. It has long been alleged that there were some "back room" deals being made, most centering on electing Hayes in exchange for ending Reconstruction and getting the "carpetbaggers" out of the South - something for which southern Democrats had been petitioning for a long time. These deals, if indeed they were made, may have smoothed over the selection of the committee members.

Ultimately all 20 disputed votes were awarded to Hayes, giving him the election by just one electoral vote, 185-184. And Tilden became the first candidate, but not the last, to loose an election while winning the popular vote. Surely those who were present at the vote-counting in Congress that February of 1877 thought that anything might happen (even though it was supposed to have been worked out in the special committee). The actual certification of the election in Congress seems to have been anticlimactic.


Condition:  
Excellent.
Sold: $264.38
Price includes
Buyer's Premium
      Ask a Question

All Images

Large Silver Print of General Lee on Traveler,
Lot # 181 - Large Silver Print of General Lee on Traveler,
10.5" x 13.5", mounted on period card stock (16" x 20"), and marked in negative lower left Copyright 1906/John Hedges. > Item Details
13-Star American Flag
Lot # 212 - 13-Star American Flag
probably post-Civil War boat flag. Made of worsted wool with 13 zig-zag stars of equal sizes and 13 machine sewn stripes. With sleeve and steel gromets. Approx 45" x 30". > Item Details
<i>Fort Clark</i>, Carl Bodmer Etching and Aquatint
Lot # 216 - Fort Clark, Carl Bodmer Etching and Aquatint
Print titled Fort Clark. On the Missouri (February 1834), with Bodmer's blindstamp, published by Ackermann & Co.; 16.5 x 21.75 in. (sight), framed and glazed, 19 x 24.25 in. > Item Details
California 1894 Reward Broadside,
Lot # 342 - California 1894 Reward Broadside,
Rare wanted poster from San Bernadino county. Reads Whereas, on the twenty-fourth day of October, A.D. 1894, JAMES GUILMINOT was murdered by some person or persons unknown, near Colton, in the county of San Bernadino, State of California. The governor had authorized the payment of 300 dollars for th... > Item Details
<i>General Morgan's Grand March</i> Scarce Confederate Sheet Music,
Lot # 196 - General Morgan's Grand March Scarce Confederate Sheet Music,
Peticolas, C.L. Richmond (VA): Geo. Dunn & Company, lithographed by Julian A. Selby, Columbia, SC. Copyright 1864 by Confederate States of America. 3pp, 9.5 x 12 in. Lithographed portrait of Morgan on front. Two pages of music, no lyrics. John Hunt Morgan (1826-1864) was born in Alabama but spent mo... > Item Details
<i>Goupil Gallery of Great War Paintings:</i>
Lot # 122 - Goupil Gallery of Great War Paintings:
A Collection of Photogravures from the Modern Paintings of the Paris Salon with Biographical and Descriptive Text. Boston: Estes and Lauriat, 1890. 4to, brown cloth illustrated boards with gilt front. Ten gravures with protective pages, each with about 2 pages of description. Most images relate to t... > Item Details
Large Civil War Era CDV Album
Lot # 44 - Large Civil War Era CDV Album
With some later cdvs and tintypes. 50 cdvs, one gem-sized tintype and one cdv-sized tintype. A few from the 1870s, but most just before the Civil War through the war years. About ten are commercially produced cdvs, with lithographs of Queen Elizabeth, Marie Antoinette, William Penn, puppies, anothe... > Item Details
19th Century Ephemera from Publishers and Manufacturers of Political Campaign Badges
Lot # 71 - 19th Century Ephemera from Publishers and Manufacturers of Political Campaign Badges
An interesting collection, comprised of five items. All from the 1884 campaign of James G. Blaine and John "Blackjack" Logan. Includes the following: an ALS from F.W. Hoffman and Sons of New York, with attached brass spread-winged eagle hanger; an 8.5 x 5.5 in. sheet illustrating an "eagle torch l... > Item Details
Former Slave Stephen Smith's Printed Will, 1873,
Lot # 81 - Former Slave Stephen Smith's Printed Will, 1873,
Philadelphia: no publisher or date listed, other than date of death, 14 Nov. 1873. 8vo, 12pp in paper wraps. Stephen Smith was born into slavery in 1795 in either Lancaster or Dauphin Co., PA or Cecil Co., MD, depending on the source consulted. Some sources then say he was indentured to General Thom... > Item Details
Early Montana Billhead Collection,
Lot # 317 - Early Montana Billhead Collection,
56 items, 55 from Montana, ranging from 1878 to 1915. These billheads represent everything from mining to railroads, farriers to undertakers, hotels, saloons and brewers to the penitentiary, in addition to the general merchants. Some are certainly from better-known towns, such as Missoula, Helena, B... > Item Details
Early 19th Century Travel Account from Norwich, CT to Mount Pleasant
Lot # 108 - Early 19th Century Travel Account from Norwich, CT to Mount Pleasant
Ms account of a trip. September 15th, 1830. 7.9 x 9 in. An interesting account of a trip from Norwich, CT aboard ships and stage coaches to Mount Pleasant, and return trip. Included is an account of costs incurred. On verso, Since man to man is so unjust, 'tis hard to tell what man to trust. > Item Details
Civil War Bound Volume General Orders for 1861 Including Custer,
Lot # 201 - Civil War Bound Volume General Orders for 1861 Including Custer,
Inside cover labeled Index of General Orders, Adjutant General's Office. 1861. Washington: Government Printing Office. 1862. Among 111 general orders includes #41 for Custer's first military appointment to 2nd Lt. of Co. G, 2nd regiment, U.S. cavalry. Includes index of general's names. > Item Details
CDV of Armless Artist Painting Self Portrait with His Feet
Lot # 38 - CDV of Armless Artist Painting Self Portrait with His Feet
CDV of Charles Felu (1830-1900), Belgian artist, painting with his feet. The toes are cut out of his socks so that he can paint with his feet, gripping the paintbrush with his right foot and the palette with the other. His slippers are on the floor beneath him. Bottom marked J. Maes Phot. Anvers, an... > Item Details
1816 Invoice for Crockery, Corlies Pottery, NY
Lot # 106 - 1816 Invoice for Crockery, Corlies Pottery, NY
Bill of sale to J.K. & J.A. Woods. New York, 5 Ma? 1816. Approx. 8 x 12.75 in. 38 wholesale purchases include plates, dishes, jugs, mugs, tumblers, decanters, wash basins, coffees, sauce boats, sugars, and more - by the dozen. Total $244.84. Some difficult to read, even for the 18th century, plus ma... > Item Details
Bernhardt Wall Autograph Letter and Engraving,
Lot # 115 - Bernhardt Wall Autograph Letter and Engraving,
Wall, Bernhardt (1872-1956), etcher. ALS, 3pg, 9 x 11.25 in. New York City, Feb. 11, 1919. Adressed to Judy EJ Lauer. In this letter, Bernhardt explains to Lauer how he sent President Woodrow Wilson two prints he made, and how Wilson returned one of those prints, which is included in the letter. In ... > Item Details
Jefferson Davis Cabinet Card,
Lot # 177 - Jefferson Davis Cabinet Card,
with stamp of W.W. Foster, Richmond, VA. A fine post-war portrait of the war-weary president. > Item Details
Knights Templar Booklets and Publication from Denver, CO
Lot # 130 - Knights Templar Booklets and Publication from Denver, CO
Includes 2 1892 booklets Knights Templar Conclave, Denver, Colorado, and The Great Rock Island Route, both printed by F.C. Foster & Co., Chicago, Illinois. These two promotional booklets seem to have been a cooperative venture of the Kansas and Iowa Knights Templar, the city of Denver, Colorado, and... > Item Details
Marine Engineers Beneficial Association Souvenir Manual
Lot # 334 - Marine Engineers Beneficial Association Souvenir Manual
1897 booklet Marine Engineers Beneficial Association Souvenir Manual and Directory of Members, San Francisco, California. Includes a list of officers, trustees and deligates, as well as a lengthy alphabetized directory of members, and some unusual text on first aid. > Item Details
Samuel Fessenden, Connecticut 1903 Letter
Lot # 72 - Samuel Fessenden, Connecticut 1903 Letter
6pp, 5.5 x 8.5 in., Stamford (CT): 20 Dec. 1903, on Fessenden Law Offices note paper. To his daughter Helen. Content mostly personal, beginning with his description of an illness that had lasted a couple weeks. He then encourages his daughter to expand her circle of friends beyond the family, and no... > Item Details
John C. Fremont Cabinet Card Photograph,
Lot # 176 - John C. Fremont Cabinet Card Photograph,
Cabinet card of John C. Fremont. Image shows Fremont in uniform with hands perched on top of sword. Reverse side labeled in pencil John C. Fremont. > Item Details
ITEMS 1-20 of 20
SKIP TO PAGE: