Lot 259    

Mary Ann Moorman Polaroid Photographs Capturing John F. Kennedy's Assassination
11/15/2013 - American History: Live Salesroom Auction
Description:  A pair of unique, Polaroid prints, silver diffusion transfer (Polaroid roll film Type37), each approximately 2.5 x 3.5 in., one numbered 3 on verso, the other numbered 5 .

These are numbers 3 and 5 of an 8 image pack taken on November 22, 1963.

These compelling images capture one of the most newsworthy events in American history:  the assassination of President John F. Kennedy.   One of the two is generally accepted as showing the near exact moment at which Lee Harvey Oswald’s first bullet struck the doomed President. Taken by bystander Mary Ann Moorman, these images were widely circulated at the time of the assassination, though curiously were never included in the Warren Commission Report.  Never before publicly exhibited, these remarkable photographs are center pieces of J.F.K. , November 22, 1963:  A Bystander’s View of History recently mounted by the International Center of Photography in New York, City.

Mary Ann Moorman:  Eyewitness to History

On November 22, 1963, Mary Ann Moorman, a  thirty-one year old housewife and her friend Jean Hill drove to downtown Dallas, Texas hoping to catch a glimpse of the motorcade of President John F. Kennedy.  The young, immensely popular 35th  President was in town for a luncheon at the Dallas Trade Center.  The excitement that day was palpable; huge crowds were expected to line the way of the motorcade from Love Field to the Trade Center.   Mary Ann took her Polaroid camera, hoping she could capture something to show her eleven- year-old son Ricky who was in school that day. "Truth be told," Moorman remembers, "We both wanted to see Jackie."
  
Arriving downtown about 10:30 in the morning, they parked their car on Main street, and, after realizing the Polaroid needed more film, purchased an 8-pack at a nearby department store.  They stopped at Mary Ann’s Thunderbird and took two photographs, one of each other standing or sitting by the car. Jean kept those “test” photographs, the first two in the pack.

Walking towards Houston Street, they found the sidewalks were already crowded with spectators.  They turned the corner at Elm and found a grassy area on Dealey Plaza opposite the Texas Book Repository sparsely populated.  It was a misty morning and both wore raincoats, Moorman in blue, Hill in red.  They took up a position that placed them in what they felt would be the direct line of the motorcade. As the morning cleared, they continued to wear their blue and red coats. They waited.
A motorcycle policeman approached, and Moorman recognized him as Glenn McBride, an old childhood friend, and took a picture.  They coated the Polaroid with the chemical pad to fix the image, and Mary Ann pocketed the print, her third picture of the day.   Shortly afterwards another motorcycle approached, driven by George Lumpkin, whom Mary recognized as working the traffic detail at her church on Sunday.   Stepping into the street, she took Lumpkin’s picture, and later gave it to him as his souvenir of the day when the President came to town.
Stepping back onto the grass, Mary Ann and Jean now saw the Presidential motorcade turn the corner onto Elm.  Now the President and Jackie were clearly visible.  Jackie was wearing a bright pink dress - "Pink!" - Mary Ann and Jean commented to each other.

Moorman lifted her camera to take the fifth of her eight photo pack.  It would be the last picture she would take that day.  With the presidential limousine merely feet away, she pushed the button to activate the shutter, and heard Jean yell “Mr. President, look this way, we want to take a picture.”   Later that day, she gave official testimony to the Dallas County Sheriff’s office, describing what she had just recorded on film:

"As I snapped the picture of President Kennedy, I heard a shot ring out. President Kennedy kind of slumped over. Then I heard another shot ring out and Mrs. Kennedy jumped up in the car and said ‘My God he has been shot.’ When I heard these shots ring out, I fell to the ground to keep from being hit myself. I heard three or four shots in all. After the pictures were developed, the picture of President Kennedy showed him slumped over. When the pictures were developed, they came out real light. These pictures have been turned over to Officers investigating this incident."

Mary Ann’s photograph is generally acknowledged to show the President at the near instant he was hit by the first of three bullets that Lee Harvey Oswald fired from the Texas Book Repository. In the chaotic moments after the assassination, Moorman can be seen in other surviving photographs of the scene, including a widely circulated image of her being questioned by a newspaperman, and she and Hill are clearly visible in frame number 298 of the  famous film taken by Abraham Zapruder. Both wear their raincoats, Mary Ann with her Polaroid camera to her eye.

Controversies have swirled around Moorman’s photographs just as they have around nearly every aspect of the assassination and its witnesses.  After the assassination, Jean Hill (1931-2000), Moorman’s companion spoke repeatedly  - and inconsistently -  about the events  that day, and whether intentionally or accidentally,  provided fodder for  conspiracy theorists.  For her part, however, Mary Ann Moorman has remained largely silent until very recently, when she has granted several extensive interviews.  Her recollections about that dreadful day remain unchanged from the deposition she gave in 1963. Regardless, for many conspiracy theorists, Moorman’s Polaroids are like a Rosetta  Stone for unlocking the secrets of the assassination.

Mary Ann Moorman:  Citizen Journalist

Beyond their historical significance, these images mark the dawn of an era. In a day where hundreds of millions of photographs and videos are taken daily by cell phone users --  many of which record newsworthy events  -- it is easy to forget that at the time Moorman took these photographs, photo-journalism was almost exclusively the  domain of professionals.   Newspapers in every major city had special departments employing professional photographers whose sole job was to ensure that they were in the right place at the right time to “get the picture.”   Much of what passed as “news” photos were carefully staged photo-ops where the news photographer was part of a “scrum” of press, waiting patiently with a cumbersome Speed-graphic, or later, 35mm camera.

The exception, of course, was the combat photographer.  Robert Capa had produced unforgettable images during the Spanish Civil War; during World War II and the Korean War that followed, official Army photographers routinely sent back images that captured the immediacy of the moment.   At the time of Kennedy’s assassination, the War in Vietnam was just beginning to ramp up.  Soon, Americans would view the horrors of war nightly on their televisions.

But in 1963, America was at the dawn of the mass-media era; television was still in its infancy, and the American consumer was being exposed to new advances in photography.  While Edwin Land had invented instant film in the years following World War II, the Polaroid camera that Moorman used on that November day was still new to the market and because of its price, out of reach for many.   Just a few months earlier, Kodak, long a leader in making photography available to the average consumer, introduced the Instamatic  in February, 1963.   Between 1963 and 1970, when the line was discontinued, more than 50 million Instamatics were sold.

The rise of mass media in the 1960s developed a new sort of intimacy between the American public and public figures.   Kennedy, probably the most photographed President of the 20th century, early on recognized the power of television and used it to his benefit during his 1960 campaign debate with Richard Nixon.  He also recognized the importance of the rope-line, where supporters could “snap” a picture of the candidate and later use it as a trophy of their moment in history. Moorman’s photographs, though not much to look at, must be viewed through this historical lens.  She was not a professional, merely a bystander with a camera.  And yet, as Brian Wallis, Curator of the International Center Photograph has so aptly pointed out, she was only one of a number of amateur photographers that day, all of whom beat the professional media to the punch.  In the aftermath of the assassination, the images these casual picture-makers captured challenged the classical notion of photojournalism.   While the professionals were waiting for their photo-op at the Dallas Trade Center the real news pictures – grainy and blurry, yet horrifying in their intimacy – were being made by some of the first, unsuspecting citizen-journalists.
As imperfect as they may be, this pair of images -- from one of the most memorable days in the last half century of American history --  are icons of national importance, as much for the history they have left, as the history they recorded.
 
Exhibited:

J.F.K. November 22, 1963: A Bystander’s View of History.  International Center of Photography.  October 4, 2013-January 19, 2014.  (Note: The photographs will be removed from the exhibit and returned to Cowan’s Auctions, Inc. on November 11, 2013.)

Notes:

1. Cowan’s is grateful for discussions with Brian Wallis, Curator of Photography at the International Center of Photography, and who is the organizer of the recent exhibit : J.F.K. November 22, 1963:  A Bystander’s View of History which explores the role of the amateur photographer in recording events in Dallas on the day of the assassination.  Moorman’s photographs were publicly exhibited here for the first time.

2.  Cowan’s also wishes to acknowledge both the personal verbal history communicated by Mary Ann Moorman Krahmer, as well as her interview with Mr. Gary Stover, in 2011, the transcript of which can be found online (http://www.iantique.com/pages/Mary-Moorman-Interview-Transcript).

3.  A condition report by Slyvie Pénichon, Conservator of Photographs at the Amon Cater Museum accompanies each photograph. 
Sold: $52,875.00
Price includes
Buyer's Premium
      Ask a Question

All Images

don't miss

an opportunity to bid. You can't win if you're not in.

sign up to bid

what's it worth?

ask the experts

sell your item

start selling
2nd Lieut. Frederick E. Garnett, 74th New York Infantry, WIA Gettysburg, Autographed CDV
Lot # 105 - 2nd Lieut. Frederick E. Garnett, 74th New York Infantry, WIA Gettysburg, Autographed CDV
Carte ink signed on verso Yours Truly/ Frederick E. Garnett, with Gurney & Son's New York imprint. Frederick E. Garnett enlisted as a Private on 5/61, and mustered into Co. B, 6/61; promoted to Sergeant, 6/62; 2nd Lieut. of Co. E, 6/63; 1st Lieut. of Co. H, 9/63; WIA at Gettysburg, 7/2/... > Item Details
Charles J. Belden Photograph of a Sheep Camp
Lot # 391 - Charles J. Belden Photograph of a Sheep Camp
Silver gelatin photograph of two men tending the chuck wagon at a sheep camp on the expansive Wyoming range, unmarked, but by Charles Belden, ca 1910s-1940s, 16 x 19.75 in. Charles J. Belden (1888-1963) was born in San Francisco into a wealthy California family. He developed a life-long passion f... > Item Details
Custer Family Genealogies & Related Materials, Plus a Family Copy of <i>Boots & Saddles</i>
Lot # 346 - Custer Family Genealogies & Related Materials, Plus a Family Copy of Boots & Saddles
Lot of 4 books and 35+ documents/ photocopied papers related to the Custer family and its genealogy.  The books include: Custer, Milo. Custer Genealogies. Bloomington (IL): 1944. 8vo, paper wrappers, 98pp; Custer, Milo. Custer Genealogies. Bloomington (IL): 1944... > Item Details
CSA Major John Breckinridge Castleman, ALS to General John Hunt Morgan, January 15, 1864
Lot # 428 - CSA Major John Breckinridge Castleman, ALS to General John Hunt Morgan, January 15, 1864
John Breckinridge Castleman (1841-1918). ALS, 1p, 7.5 x 9.5 in., Columbia, SC, Jan 13, 1864. Addressed to General John Hunt Morgan, asking him to submit a more accurate record of his wartime exploits than the one Castleman was able to compile for the "Board of Gentlemen" of South Carolina. Signed J.... > Item Details
Identified Naval Officers, Five CDVs
Lot # 95 - Identified Naval Officers, Five CDVs
Including a compact group shot of five uniformed officers who served aboard the USS Monongahela, with Washburn, N.O. imprint and orange two-cent revenue stamp. Penciled at left is Lieut. P.J. Langer who joined 11/62 as 3rd Assistant Engineer; promoted 2nd Assistant Engineer 3/64; resigned 4/28/... > Item Details
Robert Todd Lincoln Autographed Large Format Photograph
Lot # 254 - Robert Todd Lincoln Autographed Large Format Photograph
Robert Todd Lincoln (1843-1926). Abraham Lincoln's only son to live into adulthood; served as Secretary of War under Presidents Garfield and Arthur.  12.5 x 16 in. photograph, signed lower right by the photographer (A. Cole?), on a 17.75 x 22 in. mount signed by Lincoln in the lower margin ... > Item Details
<i>Texas</i> Map with Inset of Galveston Bay, by C. Flemming, Ca 1845
Lot # 410 - Texas Map with Inset of Galveston Bay, by C. Flemming, Ca 1845
Flemming, Carl. Texas. Glogau (formerly Silesia, now in Poland): C. Flemming, ca 1845. Overall 14 x 17.5 in., neat lines, 12.5 x 15.5 in. Smaller reissue of John Arrowsmith's important German map of the Republic of Texas, just before its admission to the Union at the end of 1845. It shows the ex... > Item Details
Sixth Plate Daguerreotype of an Identified Miner by R.H. Vance, San Francisco, California
Lot # 367 - Sixth Plate Daguerreotype of an Identified Miner by R.H. Vance, San Francisco, California
Sixth plate daguerreotype of a bearded miner wearing a stern expression, housed in a case with San Francisco daguerreian Robert. H. Vance's imprinted pad. A period, inked note pinned to the pad identifies the sitter as Pardee Bench(?). Housed in a floral, leather case. Although an unusual n... > Item Details
1st Maine Cavalry, Two CDVs of Colonel John Goddard
Lot # 28 - 1st Maine Cavalry, Two CDVs of Colonel John Goddard
Lot of two, including a common view of Colonel John Goddard, by Butler & King, Portland. Colonel Goddard served only briefly, commissioned Colonel 10/61; resigned 3/1/62.  The group shot by T.R. Burnham, Portland is Colonel Goddard and his sons, (L) Private Charles W. Goddard, and (M) 1s... > Item Details
Occupational Sixth Plate Ambrotype of a Carpenter
Lot # 222 - Occupational Sixth Plate Ambrotype of a Carpenter
Sixth plate ambrotype of a carpenter in profile, holding a square and planer, with mitre and panel saws visible hanging above his workbench.  Housed in full leather case with floral design. > Item Details
7th Maine Battery, Four CDVs of Identified Soldiers
Lot # 26 - 7th Maine Battery, Four CDVs of Identified Soldiers
One officer and three enlisted men, one a pair of seated pards. The officer is tentatively identified as Capt. Adelbert B. Twitchell by Wm Pierce, Brunswick, Me. The captain wears a shield-shaped ID badge on his frock coat. Twitchell had prior service in the 5th Maine Battery as ... > Item Details
Civil War Ivory-Handled Walking Cane Identified to <i>R. Wilson 5 Cav. 1864</i>, POW at Beaver Dam
Lot # 153 - Civil War Ivory-Handled Walking Cane Identified to R. Wilson 5 Cav. 1864, POW at Beaver Dam
33.5 in. ln., ferrule 1.375 in.; ivory handle with scrimshaw rendering of the Great Seal of the United States on one side and R. Wilson 5 Cav. 1864 on other, mounted on a wooden shaft. Robert Phillips Wilson enlisted as a 1st Lieut. and was commissioned into Field &a... > Item Details
James A. Garfield ALS to Edwin M. Stanton, July 2, 1864
Lot # 454 - James A. Garfield ALS to Edwin M. Stanton, July 2, 1864
James Abram Garfield (1831-1881).  20th President of the United States (1881).  ALS as U.S. Representative, 3pp, 8vo, dated at House of Representatives, July 2, 1864, addressed to Secretary of War Edwin M. Stanton, recommending a staff appointment for J.W. Burke, 10th Ohio Volunteers, who ... > Item Details
Identified USCT Officers from Maine, Six CDVs
Lot # 88 - Identified USCT Officers from Maine, Six CDVs
First is inked Edgar E. Adams, with J.W. Petty, N.O. back mark. Adams had prior service as Private, Co. C, 2nd VT.; POW Savage Station, VA 6/29/62, paroled; discharged for disability; commissioned Captain Co. B, 75th USCT 12/63; promoted Major, 73rd USCT, 11/64; discharged 9/27/65. A tintype mounted... > Item Details
Marquis de Lafayette Papier-Mache, Memorial Snuff Box
Lot # 229 - Marquis de Lafayette Papier-Mache, Memorial Snuff Box
Papier-mache snuff box featuring transfer decal portrait of Marquis de Lafayette within a wreath of clouds, commemorating his death, which occurred on May 20, 1834, surrounded by the following: May a grateful people ever estimate his services/ Genal. Lafayette. Ca 1830s. 3.5 in. dia., .75 in. ht.&nb... > Item Details
Union General William Rosecrans, 1863, Albumen Photograph
Lot # 121 - Union General William Rosecrans, 1863, Albumen Photograph
Albumen photograph captioned on mount below image, Genl. Rosecrans 1863. Lacking a photographer's imprint. Most likely taken at the campsite at Stones River, TN. 5.5 x 8 in., mounted, 7.75 x 9.5 in. With modern, inked identification on mount verso.  William Rosecrans (1819-1898), so... > Item Details
1st Lieut., Eugene P. Jacobson, 74th New York Infantry, CMOH Chancellorsville, Autographed CDV
Lot # 104 - 1st Lieut., Eugene P. Jacobson, 74th New York Infantry, CMOH Chancellorsville, Autographed CDV
Albumen carte with Henry Ulke's Washington, D.C. backmark, signed on verso, Ever truly yours/ Eugene P. Jacobson/ 1st Lieut. 5th Excelsior. Eugene Philip Jacobson (1841-1881) was commissioned Corporal, Co. B, 6/62; promoted Sergeant Major of Field & Staff, 9/62; 2nd Lieut. 5/63; an... > Item Details
Identified Naval Officers, Five CDVs
Lot # 96 - Identified Naval Officers, Five CDVs
One a civilian view of Paymaster Daniel C. Burleigh, retired 6/30/79. Another, a small albumen mounted on card stock (a mini cdv) measuring 1.25 x 2.25 in., identified as Acting Engineer John D. Williams; 3rd Acting Engineer 5/64; resigned 3/16/65.  Another view of Captain James B. Alden, ink s... > Item Details
Identified QM Dept. Officers from Maine including BBG, Four CDVs
Lot # 86 - Identified QM Dept. Officers from Maine including BBG, Four CDVs
Group includes a carte of career regular Lieut. Colonel G. Sawtelle (1834-1913) and unidentified junior officer having the imprint of Anderson, N.O. with blue-green two-cent revenue stamp. Sawtelle graduated the USMA ’54 and became QM 2/57; promoted 1st Lieut. 6/60; Captain 5/61; Lie... > Item Details
Hannibal & St. Joseph Railroad, 500,000 Acres of the Best Prairie, Timber and Coal Lands in the West!, Spectacular Broadside
Lot # 401 - Hannibal & St. Joseph Railroad, 500,000 Acres of the Best Prairie, Timber and Coal Lands in the West!, Spectacular Broadside
Spectacular six-color broadside for the sale of Missouri lands by the Hannibal & St. Joseph's Railroad; 22 x 27.75 in.; Matthews & Warren, Buffalo, NY, printers.  Post-Civil War, ca 1866-1868, with Missouri Is Free! in patriotic lettering at top, offering 500,000 Acres of the Best P... > Item Details
ITEMS 1-20 of 20
SKIP TO PAGE: